[mfm] I let my best friend fuck my wife. Part 2

(See profile for part 1. sorry for posting again it got removed the first time)

So like I said I thought about it a lot the next day. I actually tried to put it out of my mind because I have a tendency to obsess over stuff like this and I didn’t want to overdo it, but it was hard not to think about. I knew right away that I wasn’t jealous for her being attracted to him – thinking about it now I’m actually so glad it worked out this way, that the person she was hot for was someone who means so much to me. The only thing that worried me was whether it had been a mistake to ask her point blank if she wanted to fuck him, because the fact that I hadn’t been mad about it kinda gave away that I was potentially into the idea, and maybe she’d feel like that was weird. But by the time I got home from work that day I was sure of two things: one that I had to know whether she would seriously be interested in sleeping with him, and two that if the answer was yes I was going to tell her she could.

So after dinner we sit on the couch and I ambush her with it a little bit, saying I want to talk about what we said last night, and I guess I was a little awkward with it because at first she thought I was upset and started assuring me again that nothing was ever going to happen (lol) and it was just a funny moment. And maybe the normal thing to do would have been leave it there, but I wanted to make sure she knew how I felt. So I just get up my nerve and came out with it and I say listen, not only am I not upset but I’m into it, and if you want it to happen then I want it to happen too. And she takes a minute to make sure I’m really ok and being serious with what I’m saying, and then she gets real shy and gives me a little smile and says, ok. Let’s do it.

And my heart fucking races at that, and in the back of my mind I know I am supposed to be feeling jealous but I’m just not. All I can think about is how exciting this is and how I love seeing her turned on, and I absolutely cannot wait to make this happen. I know I should probably take some time and cool off before I rush into it but I just can’t stop myself from wanting to tell Ryan right away so I start texting him. Chrissy laughs and starts looking over my shoulder at what I’m writing at first but after a while she says just tell me what happens and she goes to another room.

Unfortunately I got a new phone since then so I can’t look up the actual texts, but I remember how it went pretty clearly. I was pretty nervous because I really didn’t want to make things weird between us but I pushed passed it and just went right into it and told him Chrissy and I were talking about him last night. I tell him we both want him to know that Chrissy finds him attractive. He replies with “lol ok?” which makes sense because it’s kind of a weird thing to come out of nowhere, so I say “just thought you should know”. I know I don’t need to ask the next question because over the years he’s given me a few veiled suggestions that he thinks I’m a lucky guy and “punching above my weight”, but I ask anyway: “do you find her attractive?”

But instead of replying directly he just asks me right away why I’m asking him that, and now I feel bad for weirding him out, so there’s nothing for it but to explain the whole thing, so I write a super long text telling him that Chrissy and I decided to try exploring new things in our marriage and that she confessed to having a crush on him and I wanted her to explore it, and it’s fine if he has no interest & sorry if it’s weird but basically he’s the only guy I know that I would ever consider allowing something like this with.

Ryan takes a long time to respond and finally says he’s really honored but he doesn’t know what to think, & he doesn’t want anything to be weird between us. So at that point I think he’s just not interested and turning us down so I say that’s totally fine, don’t worry about it. But I can’t resist not giving up right away so I say he didn’t answer my question about finding her attractive.

He takes a while to respond again but then says “Yeah she is hot as fuck you know that. you are a lucky guy.” So then I know what to do next.

I go to Chrissy upstairs and right away she asks what Ryan said. Kinda obvious how eager she is. So I tell her everything we’ve said so far and I say I want to send him a nude. She gets a little bit shy again but says yes so I ask which one she wants me to send (she’s pretty familiar with the collection I have of her!) and she says why not just take a new one. So she stands up and goes over to the hallway where the lighting is good and looks me dead in the eye as she gets undressed until all she’s wearing is a thin red silk robe hanging open and she poses up against the wall for me. Big brown eyes looking right at the camera, long dark hair hanging down to her big soft tits, sexy smooth thighs, and I take a picture. Still my favorite ever nude of her and honestly imo the sexiest pic I have ever seen of any woman, and I’m so damn hard and excited I don’t hesitate for a second and send it to Ryan immediately. He responds right away:

“Holy shit. wow she’s so fucking sexy. you guys are really serious about this huh.”

At this point I’m so tense and turned on I’m actually shaking. I sit down next to Chrissy so she can see the conversation and I write “do you want to fuck her?” and give her the phone and she hits send. We start making out right there in the hallway and I’m so hard I want to fuck her right there on the floor but instead I wait for Ryan’s response and he writes back:
“I want her so bad. If you guys are sure this is what you want I will come over there right now and fuck her all night.” And about 20 seconds after that he sends me his own pic. Honestly I can say his pic is not quite as artful as ours was, pretty much just a classic dick pic with a bit of his stomach and body in there but he has a nice looking dick and I can see he’s hard as fuck just like I am. So Chrissy blushes and laughs and I ask if she’s still sure she wants to do this and she says yes absolutely. So I write back “she’s all yours. door’s open.”

Over the course of the next hour or so is when it first starts to hit me how stupidly fast this is all moving. I don’t think I felt at any point like it was a bad idea or anything but I was acutely aware it wouldn’t have hurt to give it a week or so to think it over and make sure we were still into it. Chrissy and I talk and agree that if either of us feels weird or not into it we’ll stop it. I say I think Ryan would probably be fine with that but if for whatever reason he’s not that’ll be my problem and we’ll just deal with it later. I’m still excited and turned on but at more of a deep down level than like surface level horny if that makes sense. I start to feel like I’m organizing a social event and all I can think about is how I want everyone to have a good time. Chrissy and I have a drink and smoke half a joint to relax a little bit while we wait to see if Ryan shows.

And he does. It’s pretty late at this point but Ryan arrives and I let him in with a typical dude hug and “hey how’s it going man” as though he had just come over to hang out for something totally normal. We go over to the living room where Chrissy is sitting on the couch wearing the same robe we took the picture in, only slightly more covered up than in the picture. I ask if Ryan wants a drink and he says he’s good, and I can see he’s just looking right at Chrissy and she’s looking back the same way. So I just do my best not to sound awkward and say “Go ahead and get comfortable.”

I have to say at this point I really appreciate Ryan not making it weird by pressing me too much on what exactly we wanted to happen. When we texted earlier I think he thought we were talking about just like a regular threesome – I don’t know what that would have looked like but I know it’s not what Chrissy wanted right then and I didn’t really either, and he managed to pick up on that and just go with what we wanted without really having to ask. So when I told him to get comfortable that’s exactly what he did; went ahead and sat down on the couch next to my wife and said hi and told her she looked amazing. Then he puts a hand on her thigh and kisses her and a second later the two of them are making out in front of me. Chrissy gestures for me to come over and she held my hand as Ryan brushes her robe aside to let her big tits out and starts kissing her body.

I give Chrissy one big deep kiss as he starts kissing her nipple and touching her thighs under the robe, and she lets go of my hand and starts taking Ryan’s clothes off. I knew she was probably nervous too but less than I was I guess because she didn’t hesitate to pull his jeans down and get his cock out, and I remember sitting there watching waiting to say “go ahead” or something as encouragement for if she needed it but she didn’t because she just bends down and takes his cock into her mouth without a moment’s pause.

That’s the first moment where I started feeling actually mixed emotions about it. I got hard then but it was the kind of erection that felt like a purely physical reaction. My body was there but the rest of me was not ready yet. It’s a hard feeling to describe if you’ve never experienced it; it wasn’t entirely negative because I knew I wanted it to keep going and I could feel myself getting turned on as I watched them but I was just too overwhelmed to be enjoying it right then. I watch Chrissy suck his cock for a few minutes with her eyes closed and I coan see on her face how much she’s enjoying it, and then I feel her reach out and take my hand again to squeeze it like she’s making sure I’m right there with her.

I thought about letting it all just play out right there on the couch & I could see they probably would be happy to stay there, but I felt a little vulnerable there in the front room of the house so I ask if they want to go upstairs. Ryan looks at me for basically the first time since laying eyes on Chrissy and says “Yeah, if you want?” and I can tell what he’s saying is asking if I’m sure I want him to fuck her and I say yes. So the two of them get up and Chrissy turns to me with a big happy smile and I can see she wants this 100%, and at that point I know for sure there’s no way I’m going to stop this no matter what I’m feeling. Ryan runs his hands up Chrissy from behind and slips the robe off her shoulders and lets it fall down so she’s fully naked, his hands going all over her enjoying my wife’s body and I know there’s no hesitation from him either. It was really hot seeing how quickly he became confident with her naked body. Maybe some of that was him just knowing what I wanted to see but mostly he just wasn’t holding back how much he wanted to fuck her.

So the three of us quickly go upstairs and my heart is pounding because I know we’re crossing the point of no return here. Chrissy climbs right up on the bed and looks at me as she spreads her legs a little bit, knees bent, and she asks me to get a condom which I hadn’t even thought about. Ryan takes his clothes off and gets on the bed kneeling in front of her as I come over to the side and give him the condom. Ryan honestly looks pretty good naked. Not like a male model or anything but he has a big strong body and I’m hard as fuck looking at him naked there in front of my wife. Chrissy shifts over to the middle of the bed and says to me “come here” and puts a hand on the mattress, so I get naked too and I sit there on the bed and she holds my hand again. Then I see Ryan part her legs more and he goes down on her while Chrissy starts stroking my cock as I tell her I love her, and she says she loves me and her face is a little flushed. I look back at Ryan and I can see he’s put the condom on and Chrissy and I make out as he keeps eating her pussy, and she pulls me in and we’re making out as I hear her starting to moan.

I’m still kissing my wife as I feel his weight shift forward on the bed. I pull back from the kiss for just a second and I see her facial expression, eyes closed, mouth open slightly, face a little red and breathing heavy and it’s a face I’ve seen thousands of times before and I realize Ryan’s cock is inside her. I gently withdraw from them to watch and I move back and see Chrissy’s thighs are squeezed against Ryan’s body as his cock slides into my wife, his balls against her wet pussy lips. I suddenly become aware that for all the time I’ve spent in the last day thinking about whether or not to do this, I never took a moment to actually visualize them together like this. It’s a weird moment that feels almost unreal because this is an angle I’ve never watched outside of porn, but then as I hear the extremely familiar sound of Chrissy beginning to groan louder and more deeply it’s extremely real.

Obviously I had hoping the two of them would have a good time together, but I can honestly say I was not expecting it to be this good for her this quickly. It was probably two or three minutes before I can tell she’s about to cum, her voice is so intense and desperate as she starts saying “yes, yes, fuck me fuck me” and Ryan leans forward more so his full weight is on her and fucking pounds away at her pussy. I know Chrissy can cum really fast when she’s turned on enough and I guess that says everything you need to know about how much she wanted this because she cums really fucking loud and hard and it seems to go on forever as Ryan keeps fucking her. And hearing that moment of complete satisfaction from her becomes the only thing I need to get over my nerves because all those mixed feelings melt away and I’m just so fucking glad we’re doing this and so hard and turned on I’m ready to bust any second, which is exactly what happens because Ryan leans back a little as Chrissy finishes orgasming, she looks deep into my eyes and pulls me over to her so she can suck my cock and it takes about ten seconds before I blow my load in her mouth and it’s one of the best, most intense and satisfying orgasms I’ve ever had.

I finally sit back completely drained and I know Ryan isn’t done yet, and I also know Chrissy often doesn’t take long before she’s ready to go again, so I get off the bed and literally pull up a chair to watch and tell Ryan “go ahead man” and he laughs and eases back into fucking her. I think if it had been anyone else it would have felt pretty fucking weird being in that post nut moment watching them fuck, but because it’s him even though I’m not horny right then it’s just kinda nice watching them together, just aesthetically their bodies look great together on the bed going at it as I stroke myself and listen to Chrissy enjoying him fucking her. It turns out he is a pretty fucking good lay because he has great stamina and they get into a really good sync. Chrissy cums once more before he does and then again right at the end as he finally cums she does too right at the same time which was really fucking hot.

After that we take a minute to talk and we all kinda check in and make sure everyone’s cool with it but there’s really nothing much to say other than us all agreeing this is so much fun. Ryan says this is the best sex he’s ever had and I ask Chrissy how about her and she kinda laughs and declines to give a straight answer, lol.

Ryan ended up staying until about 3am and they fucked a bunch more throughout the night. Chrissy had probably five or six orgasms all together especially when he bent her over the bed and fucked her from behind until she was basically too exhausted to continue. They took a little break after that and then she sucked his cock again and he asked if he could cum on her so she pulled out and let him finish on her tits. We finally called it a night after that, Chrissy pretty much fell asleep in about thirty seconds and Ryan and I went back downstairs and had a beer and talked some more before he went home. I told him we’d both had a great time, he said he did too & asked whether we’d want to do this again some time. I said yeah definitely but we should probably take a while and see how we feel before we do this again. He went home and I went to join Chrissy in bed, we then had amazing sex together at about 7am before work.

Ultimately we have not done it again since; Chrissy and I did talk about asking him over again but we took a few weeks to think about it and by then it was into the holidays and we were busy traveling and stuff and then obviously soon after that Covid happened. Then about six months after that Ryan got into a relationship which by now seems to be fairly serious so that’s kind of closed the window on doing this again any time soon.

I do sometimes still have weird feelings about how crazy this whole thing was but overall I don’t have any regrets. It was the most intensely hot experience of my life and I’m glad to have done it, doubly so with a good friend, but I don’t feel any particular compulsion to make it happen again really.

That’s my story so thanks for reading, hope it wasn’t too run of the mill compared to other the kinds of stories that get posted here!

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/r2taxw/mfm_i_let_my_best_friend_fuck_my_wife_part_2