I watched my crush with two guys

Here’s a story I’m not proud of. When I was 22 I had a huge crush on this girl, Alex. I’d known her for years and had been in love with her for most of that time. She was cute as hell, funny, and had a slim hourglass figure that drove me and lots of other guys crazy. She’d only dated one guy, in high school, and I thought I was on the path with her to becoming her boyfriend. We’d cuddled a few times when we were 19 but I was too stupid to kiss her. I’d slipped my hand under her shirt and pet her side while we watched a movie. Looking back, it’s obvious that she liked me, but she was shy herself. And probably frustrated that I didn’t kiss her.

She had another guy friend who I was afraid she liked, but nothing ever came of that. She was hardworking and innocent, and I thought it was only a matter of time before we started dating.I’d frequently see other guys checking her out, but she had a terrible radar for that and never seemed to notice. She just assumed the best of everyone and had no idea how many guys wanted to get into her pants. Alex had been a dancer since she was young and had a spectacular body. Anytime I heard guys talking about her, they almost always mentioned how nice her ass was. Of course, occasionally a guy would be obvious and stupid about it and she always made fun of them. That made me feel really good, thinking that one day she would be mine.

I was too timid, though, and eventually she became more outgoing. She’d never really gone to parties or drank, but finally she started. Whenever an attractive guy would start talking to her at a party, I would get in really sour moods. I was crazy jealous, even though she never dated any of these guys.This when on until a few weeks before she turned 23, the night of this story. The night this all came crashing down was a night she threw a party.

She lived in a house with a roommate, and her roommate was out of town. It wasn’t a crazy party, maybe 30 people, but it was a good one. I was having a good time, until I noticed this guy Seth hitting on Alex. I’d known him for a few months. He was older, 29, and knew Alex through some work friends. The first thing I’d heard her say about him was that he was a jerk, so I really wasn’t worried about her dating him. Even though he was clearly a really attractive guy.So I watched him hit on her at this party, and it dawned on me that she was flirting with him. I’d never seen her really flirt with anyone, she was usually pretty shy. So seeing her touch his arm and playfully hit him, I immediately knew she liked him. That’s pretty common behavior for some girls, but I’d never seen Alex do that with anyone.The party went pretty late.Seth and Alex were with each other the whole time, and to me it was pretty obvious they were going to hook up.

I was in a terrible mood. I tried hanging around her trying to get her attention, but nothing worked. Finally there were about seven people left. A few announced they were leaving, and I did too, trying to make it seem like everyone should leave so Alex could go to sleep. Really I just wanted Seth to leave. But he didn’t, Alex just said bye, and I walked out leaving Alex alone with Seth and a few other people.Now is the part I’m really not proud of. I walked about ten minutes towards my place (I lived walking distance) when I got the idea to go back and check on her. I just had to know what was happening.

This was a really unhealthy thing for me to do, but I did it. I went back to her house and in the front door. My plan was to pretend like I couldn’t find my keys and came back for them.I went in and the party had ended. I went towards Alex’s room, dreading what I would find. The door was closed, but I heard her laughing from inside. I knew her roommate was out of town, and there was a door between their room that they always kept closed. I decided I could listen at that door, maybe even see through a crack or the keyhole. I’m not looking for anyone to tell me this was morally wrong. I know it is, and I’ve dealt with years of guilt about it.I snuck in her roommates room and went up to the door. There was a crack that was surprisingly easy to see through. I saw Alex sitting on her bed, next to Seth, and my heart sank.

They were listening to music softly and were getting close. Then, I noticed another guy in the room, Mike. Mike was a friend of Seth’s who I had met only once before. He was Seth’s age and played on some amateur sports teams with Seth. At first I was relieved, she wasn’t going to hook up with Seth.But then to my shock Seth kissed her, right in front of Mike. It was like a knife to my heart. I watched them make out, right in front of Mike. I couldn’t believe it. There was some soft music playing as they made out for a few minuets. It was a strange, quiet moment. Mike just kind of looked a his phone while Seth and Alex kissed and let their hands roam over each other. Then Seth took his shirt off, and then I kind of understood why she was so attracted to him. He was older than us, 29, and it looked like he’d spend the past decade plus in the gym. He had a sculpted physique, a plated back, a six pack. The look on Alex’s face as she ran her hands over his muscles was pure horniness. I’d had an illusion of her falling in love with me for my personality. And maybe she would’ve, but watching Seth feel her up in front of his friend, I felt like a complete idiot.

Then it was her turn. He took her shirt off, then unhooked her bra. Finally I was seeing her topless and she looked stunning, her breasts perky and supple and suddenly being groped by Seth’s large hands. Alex’s body was a perfect match for his. For as big and strong as he was, she was soft and curvy. I couldn’t figure out why she was doing this in front of Mike, until he sat down next to her. She was entwined with Seth, and looked over at Mike. Seth prodded her, “Kiss him.” I couldn’t believe it. “Come on” he said, “all girls deserve a night like this.”Mike leaned in, and they kissed. And felt her up. And I just watched, as they both felt her up. A few minutes later, Seth had his dick out and Alex stroked his considerable length. She looked absolutely drunk with lust.

Normally I’d think a girl doing something like this was really slutty. But I knew Alex wasn’t a slut, she’d barely slept with anyone. I think she did it because both guys were incredibly handsome, hyper-masucline athletes. Most girls don’t get opportunities like this, but Alex is a smokeshow herself and honestly if this is what she wanted, she deserved it.

That didn’t make it any easier to watch her give herself to them, to watch them use her like some slut they picked up at the bar. But Alex clearly got off on it. She did everything Seth told her to do with a smile on her face. He had her pants open and had his hand inside her panties while she stroked both their cocks. Then Seth told her to stand up, and he and Mike pulled the rest of her clothes off so she was completely naked. Both of their hands found her ass, which I’m sure they’d been looking at all night. Seth told her to get on the bed, on her hands and knees, and she did, with both him and Mike feeling on her ass the whole time. Seth spanked her, and Alex just looked back at him and giggled. Then he moved around to the other side, and I watched as she took his dick willingly into her mouth.

That’s all for part one, but obviously there’s more. If you want to know the details of how they took turns fucking her, feel free to message me. Despite my heartbreak it’s one of the most erotic things I’ve ever seen. I’m not looking for judgements, I know how bad this was. But if you are interested/think it’s hot/ anything else feel free to send me a chat. I found out a little more about how and why this happened later on. Thanks

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/qglaee/i_watched_my_crush_with_two_guys