This story is more funny than anything. But I thought some people might be in for a good chuckle.
One of my first girlfriends, we’ll call her Beth, had invited over to her house to chill in her room and listen to music. Her mom and stepdad were home, but we had been together long enough that they trusted us to leave the door shut.
One thing led to another and soon enough we were slowly fucking as to not be too loud. We were in the position where you’re basically spooning, and I was fucking her from behind while my chest was pressed against her back. It was divine. I could hear and feel how wet she was from the long slow strokes.
Suddenly, Beth looked over her shoulder and at me, and said “Stop for a second.” I looked at her concerned and said, “why what’s up?” She goes “stop stop!” As she hurriedly reaches down and pull a blanket over us all the way to our shoulders. Just then, the door opens, and her step-dad steps half-way in holding a tray of chocolate cupcakes. He has one half eaten one in his hand and says, “Hey Beth you wanna cupcake?”
“No thanks, I’m not hungry” she says. He then says, “Hey man you want a cupcake?” And I turn my head to face him more and reply, “I’m good man, thanks though.”
“Alright, more for me.” He says before walking out and closing the door behind him. Beth and I looked at each other for a few seconds before I whispered “what the fuck?” And then we both began laughing quietly at the fact that we had just been offered cupcakes by her step-dad while I was secretly inside her the entire time. Once our laughter had subsided, I began to stroke slowly again while kissing her shoulders and neck, and after a couple minutes, she came with a soft moan, and soon after that, I nutted in her before pulling both our pants up, patted her on the butt, kissed her cheek, and then rolled over and slowly fell asleep with a smile on my face.
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/p4wae8/the_cupcake_story_i_m18_got_caught_fucking_her_f18