In the weeks after my wife Lindsey and I enjoyed our first threesome experience with her CrossFit friend Brady, we continued to chat about what we wanted to pursue next. We talked about Brady joining us again sometime, and also about finally creating an online profile to look for other men or possibly couples.
I also learned, after seeing some of Lindsey’s texts, that she had fucked Brady at least two more times since our first encounter. We hadn’t talked about Lindsey having permission to play on her own, but it didn’t really bother me. I wish she would have told me herself, but I was glad she was becoming more free sexually and I thought it bode well for us as we continued to dive deeper into the swinging lifestyle.
Lindsey’s first time with Brady had been after a workout, in the hallway bathroom outside their gym. The second time was in Brady’s car, and apparently had created some drama, according to their texts. Brady told Lindsey that before the two of them had started fucking, he was already hooking up with another girl from the gym. They weren’t dating or anything, just FWB, but she had seen him hooking up with Lindsey in his car, and was apparently not too happy that he was fucking another woman from the gym.
Several days later, my wife brought up the possibility of Brady joining us again, but mentioned that he had a FWB that was interested in joining us in a foursome. Lindsey sounded apprehensive about seeing me with another woman, but seemed down for trying our first swapping experience. She explained the backstory to me where the other girl, Maggie, had found out about our threesome and was upset Brady hadn’t included her. Lindsey left out the part about her fucking Brady in his car, but I didn’t push it.
Lindsey and I had been talking about possibly looking for other couples online, but I had kind of assumed it would be a married couple around our age. In this case, Brady was 10 years younger than us at 25, and I was told Maggie was even younger, around 21 or 22, and they weren’t even really a couple. It wasn’t truly the dynamic we were looking for, but there was definitely something hot about the idea of us hooking up with a couple of younger, sexually uninhibited people. I didn’t even know what Maggie looked like at this point, but Lindsey assured me she was cute. I figured if Brady was fucking her she must be attractive, so I told Lindsey to set it up if everybody was interested.
By the following day, Lindsey told me that Brady and Maggie were interested in meeting that Friday, just a couple days later. The plan was to meet at Maggie’s apartment, so we could hang out in her building’s hot tub and get to know each other first.
We arrived at Maggie’s apartment at 930 on Friday night. We took the stairs to the fourth floor, and knocked on her door. Already dressed for the hot tub, Maggie answered her door in a black bikini, with a white, semi-sheer pool coverup buttoned once at her waist, but doing little to cover her tanned chest and legs.
Lindsey had been right. Maggie was cute. And definitely young. Not gorgeous by any means, but attractive nonetheless. Her brown hair was tied up in a messy bun, and her brown eyes and smile were very cute. Her nose stud was sexy, but as I’d find out later, it wasn’t her sexiest piercing. The first thing that struck me about Maggie was that she didn’t have the thick, CrossFit physique that I expected. She was tall — at least several inches taller than Lindsey, making her at least 5-9 — and somewhat slim. She had well defined arms, one of which was covered with several tattoos, and long, slender- yet-muscular legs. As she turned around to lead us into her apartment, I finally got a glimpse of her best asset. That ass was absolutely insane.
Maggie led us inside. Brady was already there, shirtless and in a pair of short swim trunks, ready to head down to the hot tub. Lindsey wasted no time peeling off her tank top and shorts, revealing her blue bikini underneath. The bottom was completely swallowed up by her ass, and Brady clearly noticed. He walked over and gave both her cheeks a squeeze as he kissed her face. Within minutes, we headed down to the first floor pool and hot tub.
Fortunately, the pool room was empty at this hour. We sat in the hot tub and chatted for about 15 minutes before things started to heat up. The tub wasn’t very big, and we sat in a circle, alternating men and women. I was across from Brady, with Maggie and Lindsey on each side of me. The flirting seemed to come easy for Brady. He was at ease with both Lindsey and Maggie. I felt like I was an awkward mess, but fortunately Maggie seemed quite comfortable. At one point, she commented that she wasn’t sure what to expect when Brady told her that I’d be 15 years older than her, but she smiled and said, “I guess I didn’t realize I had a thing for older guys until tonight.”
At first, that made me feel suddenly self conscious, since I certainly didn’t think of myself as old. Was Maggie just too young for me? Was this weird? But then, suddenly and within warning, I felt a hand on my lap under the water. I wasn’t sure if it was Lindsey or Maggie at first, but it quickly became clear it was Maggie. Her hand had landed on my thigh first, but she smiled seductively as she wasted no time placing it over my cock, rubbing softly over my trunks. She smiled even more as she felt me instantly grow hard in her hand.
She continued to rub me under the water, even as Brady’s attention turned toward her. Brady slid toward her and started kissing her, unaware that her hand was on my cock. Maggie started rubbing even harder. Finally, as my wife took a cue from Brady, and slid over to kiss me, Maggie let go. It was only about 30 seconds before I felt Lindsey’s hand on my dick. I returned the favor, pulling her thong to the side as I rubbed her clit, then slid two fingers inside her as we made out.
It was only a matter of minutes before I sensed another hand on Lindsey’s leg. Brady had scooted over and his hand was now sliding between Lindsey’s legs, joining mine. Lindsey shuddered with pleasure and moaned softly as Brady rubbed her clit and my fingers slipped in and out of her pussy. We both continued for a moment, but what I really wanted was time with Maggie. I glanced up and saw her looking at me. I slid away and moved over next to Maggie.
We instantly started kissing. Her lips were thin but soft, and she sucked gently on my lower lip. I slipped my hand under the water and ran it along Maggie’s thigh. I slowly moved it closer to her pussy as we continued to kiss, eventually reaching her lips. As I ran my fingers in gentle circles around the outside of her pussy, I felt her hand slide inside my trunks this time. She grabbed my cock confidently and firmly, and started stroking it. I slipped my fingers into her pussy and felt her quiver with delight.
Suddenly, we noticed Brady climbing out of the hot tub. He took Lindsey’s hand and helped her out, and the two of them quickly walked across the room and into the sauna, shutting the door behind them. It was a bold move, and seemed to bother Maggie, but I didn’t mind the result. She climbed on to my lap and straddled me as she swirled her tongue around mine. She lowered her hips and ground her pussy back and forth against my cock, so firmly that I could feel her pussy lips spreading around the length of cock, even through her suit and mine. Before long, she suggested we head upstairs to get a condom. She took my hand as we climbed out of the hot tub, dried off, and headed upstairs.
We made out in the elevator on the way upstairs, and immediately after she led me back into her apartment, Maggie stripped out of her wet swimming suit. I did the same.
Maggie looked phenomenal naked. Her tits were very small but perky, and her tan lines below her firm, flat stomach drew my attention to her beautiful shaved pussy. I rubbed it as we made out inside the doorway, Maggie stroking my cock at the same time.
Maggie led me into her bedroom and sat down toward the head of her bed, near her pillow. I stood in front of her, and she wasted no time swallowing my cock. There was no teasing first. She slid her lips over my cock and sucked firmly and sloppily in several long, slow motions up and down. As she took the length of my shaft into her mouth and began to swirl her tongue ring around the bottom of my cock, I had to focus really hard on not cumming so soon. She started to flick and swirl her tongue against the tip of my cock, driving me crazy as she reached into her nightstand and pulled out a condom.
As I was about to put it on, Brady and Lindsey arrived back in the apartment. Brady, already naked by the time he walked into the bedroom, came over and stood next to me. Maggie slurped the length of my cock several more times before switching to Brady’s cock. Before his cock disappeared into her mouth, the small bit of leftover cum still seeping out the tip was quite evident. It wasn’t immediately clear where he’d cum, but it seemed obvious my wife had already gotten him off once. I wondered if Maggie was tasting my wife’s pussy on his dick.
As Maggie sucked Brady, my wife leaned in close to me. She stroked my cock and leaned in close to whisper in my ear.
“Baby, I need you to fuck me,” she said. “I’m so fucking horny.”
I took her hand and pulled her around to the opposite side of the bed. She didn’t need any further direction from there. She bent over the edge of the bed, laying her face on her arms against the sheets. As she stuck her ass in the air and spread her legs apart, Brady’s cum was clearly visible seeping out of her pussy. It was so hot knowing that a younger guy like Brady was getting himself off inside my wife, but I wasn’t sure how I felt about sliding into her pussy right after. I went for it anyway.
I’d never found my wife sexier than right now as I slowly penetrated her pussy from behind. We rarely fucked doggystyle, and never standing up, bent over the bed like this. Her wide, athletic ass looked so hot as I slid into her pussy. She moaned instantly and audibly. I don’t think I’ve ever felt her pussy so wet, and as I grabbed her hips for leverage, I immediately started pounding her harder than I ever have before. Lindsey loved it, moaning and gasping loudly. As she came once, I continued to thrust in and out, though slower now, focusing on hitting all the right spots.
By now, Brady had turned Maggie around and started fucking her from behind on the other side of the bed. Maggie made continued eye contact with me as Brady slammed in and out of her. I wanted to fuck her so bad, and I could tell she wanted it too. At one point, as she and my wife very nearly faced each other, she reached out and began to play with and fondle my wife’s boobs. However, she stopped quickly when she could tell Lindsey was resisting and seemed uncomfortable. I was a bit surprised, because Lindsey and I had recently talked about her being curious about being with another woman as part of a group setting. Maybe it was just too soon.
Instead, Maggie slipped away from Brady and came over to my side of the bed. She assumed the same position as Lindsey, right next to her. There was no doubt what she wanted now. I withdrew from my wife, grabbed the condom that was now sitting on the bed, and slipped it on. Maggie was reaching back between her legs and rubbing her clit as she waited for my cock.
It was only a moment before I pushed myself inside her with almost no resistance. Like Lindsey, she was extremely wet, but she felt so much different. It had been 10 years since I’d been in any pussy other than Lindsey’s, and I’ll never forget the euphoric feeling as I entered Maggie. She was very tight, and I could feel her lips squeezing against the base of my shaft. Apparently this is what 21-year-old pussy felt like.
I slid in and out, pulling her hips toward me to penetrate her as deeply as possible. She moaned softly with each slow thrust. As I was just beginning to fuck her, I expected Brady to take another turn with my wife. Instead, he scooted across the bed and put his dick in Maggie’s mouth.
After we spit roasted Maggie, I watched Lindsey, who had suddenly been left alone. She looked increasingly frustrated as she watched her two partners fucking another woman. This had always been something that was supposed to be for both of us, and I didn’t want this to be a bad experience for her. I pulled out of Maggie, and slid my wife to the edge of the bed, her ass on the edge and her feet dangling off the side. I knelt between her legs and started to lick her pussy. I flicked her clit with my tongue and explored her outer lips for only a brief moment before pushing my tongue into her pussy. She quivered and quickly arched her back, wrapping her legs around my neck as I tongue fucked her to two more orgasms. Around the time Lindsey came for the second time, Brady also blew his load all over Maggie’s face.
By now, things were starting to wind down. Lindsey and Brady had both cum several times and had both laid down beside each other on the bed. As amazing as this had been, I had yet to cum, and I wasn’t sure Maggie had either. This didn’t seem to be lost on her. As she wiped cum off her face, she announced that she was going to go get cleaned up a bit. As she walked into the bathroom, she made eye contact with me and used her face to motion for me to come along. I followed her into the bathroom as she turned on the shower. As the water heated up, I sat down on the sink, and she slowly sucked my cock, seemingly being careful not to make me cum just yet. She stepped into the square shower and bent over the waist-high ledge on one side. I wasted no time sliding in behind her.
As I fucked her, I reached around and played with her tits for awhile, then her clit. She stood up a bit straighter now, and I wrapped my arms around her chest as I fucked her as deep as I could. I came very quickly at that point, and it’s as if she could feel my cock pulsing inside her. She too began to breathe heavily at first, and as I picked up speed, she began to moan heavily, then practically shout for me to fuck her harder. I thrusted as hard and fast as I could until she began to yell “right there”several times, until sheshrieked with pleasure as she reached climax. When she had stopped quivering, she turned around and we kissed gently for several minutes, oblivious to anything around us except the water falling on our shoulders.
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/obtb0i/first_partner_swapping_experience