Caught Between Two Friends

2 years into college and I found myself getting the hang of it. I kept up with my classes pretty easily and had a pretty active dating life including dating multiple guys. Around this time, however, I was seeing two guys on a regular basis.

At first, both relationships were super casual. Walks on the beach, dinner dates and late night talks. I thought it would be best to take things slow because I had just gotten over a pretty bad breakup.

I first met Jordan. He first noticed me as I was studying at the park, sitting on a blanket. He was chasing down a basketball and caught up to it near my blanket. The ball had just caught my eye and then I saw him running after it. I was lying on my stomach with headphones on and yelled WHAT when I saw his mouth move. Needless to say, we both chuckled and instantly hit it off.

He was at the park enjoying his day off, shooting hoops alone. He asked if I came there often as he had not seen me there before. I made a joke about him keeping track of the girls in the park and he winked and said only the pretty ones. We exchanged numbers and then he returned to the basketball court saying he would text me later.

About a week went by and while leaving the campus library, I saw this incredibly ripped guy holding the door open as I was walking out and he was walking in. We made eye contact and right then and there, I was locked onto him. He smiled, bid me a good day and made it no secret he was checking me out. I smiled back and told him thank you and after a little hesitation he asked me for my number.

He introduced himself as Noah and after initially sending me a text so I could lock his number in, we immediately began chatting. He told me he worked overnight at a warehouse and took online classes for a degree in sports medicine. We kept the conversation going until he had to go to work and I fell asleep thinking about what his lips felt like.

Fast forward about 3 months later and I had been seeing both of them 1-2 times per week. Jordan had a kind way about him and a giving spirit. Noah was an alpha male and very driven. I saw some similarities like their age, background and hobbies but in a lot of ways they were very different.

Jordan took me to an outdoor concert and we sat up on a hill to get a good view of the stage. We arrived just in time for the 3rd set and stretched out a blanket to sit on. Along with some edibles, Jordan snuck in a small bottle of vodka. We ate some snacks that we purchased on the way in and munched on the edibles. We took turns sipping the vodka and before long I was completely relaxed. Once the edibles, a chocolate brownie with a gooey center set in, I felt very aroused.

Before long we were making out and his hand found its way between my legs, caressing my inner thighs. I was wearing skimpy, skin tight, white shorts and a cropped halter top with no bra. My nipples were poking against the fabric and he began to pull and tease them. I felt my pussy heating up and I spread my legs, urging him to feel my tingling pussy.

He slipped his hand into my shorts and began to rub my pussy through my panties and I let out a soft moan. I was instantly soaking through my panties. He mentioned how warm and wet I felt and then slipped two fingers underneath my panties, inside of me. We kept making out as he was an extremely passionate kisser. We were oblivious to the people around us as I inched closer and closer to cumming. I bucked my hips against his fingers as he held his lips on mine in an attempt to muffle my moans. My legs began to shake and my toes curled as an orgasm washed over me. Jordan sucked his fingers clean and then kissed me deeply telling me to taste myself on his tongue. I was barely recovering from one orgasm when my pussy began to throb hearing his words.

That night at his place, he licked my clit and finger fucked me until I came again. He was so good with his tongue. We cuddled before I eventually headed home. We made plans for the next time we saw each other and he offered to make us dinner so we could enjoy a quiet night in.

A few days later, I had a chance to spend time with Noah. We planned to study together at the library and had reserved a study room. While it was a private room it was surrounded by windows so you were visible to the rest of the library. We met up around 2pm as he was scheduled to work his overnight shift that night. This was the first time we were meeting up to study. He kept saying how hard it was to study because he couldn’t stop staring at his pretty study partner.

He eventually grabbed my face and kissed me. His lips were plump but incredibly soft. He liked to kiss slowly and suck on my lips. It was making me so wet. He grabbed my hand and put it on his lap and I could feel how hard he was. I tried to be as discreet as possible as I slipped my hand into his jeans and found his throbbing cock. I started stroking him while we both kept our focus on the open books in front of us. I would occasionally look up to make sure no one was watching us.

He leaned back in his chair as I sped up my pace. He told me to taste his cock as I felt warm liquid spill onto my hand. I leaned over and took his head into my mouth. Precum dribbled out of his tip as I pulled away and I bent down to quickly slurp it up. Sitting up straight in my chair, I kept pumping his cock and soon he was spurting cum that was hitting the underside of the table. Most of it landed there or on the carpet underneath.

He went to the bathroom to clean himself up and I licked what little of his warm cum got onto my hand and then I resumed studying, tasting him on my lips. His cum tasted really good and I told him so after he rejoined me at the table a few minutes later. Before leaving the library, we made out by our cars and he promised he would come by my apartment that I shared with a roommate after his shift ended at 6am. Have that pussy wet and waiting he said. I loved when he said shit like that to me.

Before dawn, I was letting him in wearing nothing but a tank top and thong. He smacked my ass on the way to my room and closed the door behind us. I crawled onto my bed and he motioned for me to come to the edge of the bed. He sat down on the edge of the bed and unzipped his pants. I lowered them to his ankles and his thick cock sprang up in front of my face. He stopped me from squatting down in front of him and said no I told you to be wet so I need to make sure you are.

He told me to turn around and as I did, I lifted my shirt, exposing my H cup breasts. My fleshy, round bottom caused my thong not to be visible. After giving each cheek a smack, he ran his finger along my pussy and was satisfied that I was moist with anticipation. I turned around and lowered my mouth on his cock as I got into a squatted position. My legs were spread wide and the coolness from the air chilled the wet spot on my thong that was stuck to my pussy. He held the sides of my face as he got into position, scooting to the edge of the bed. He began to fuck up into my face, raising his hips slightly in rhythm with moving my head up and down. I gagged and saliva covered his cock, helping me fit more of him into my mouth.

The tip of his cock hit the back of my throat and he moaned. He sped up his pace slightly and that caused my pussy to throb. He kept saying yeah take me deep and increased his speed a little more. I kept up with his thrusts and soon I felt his cum fill my throat. I swiftly gulped it down. He slowed his pace but never moved his hand that was now on the back of my head, keeping his cock lodged deep in my throat. His cock had barely begun to soften in my mouth before he was at full attention again. He resumed his thrusts into my face and said he wasn’t done yet and began pumping rapidly.

Finally, he let me up and put his arms around my waist and pulled me on top of him. He told me to lay down so I crawled up to the head of the bed. He followed after undressing and peeled my thong out of my dripping slit. He lowered his head to my pussy and he began kissing and flicking my clit with his tongue. He said I had a pretty pussy and then I felt his head at my entrance. I scooted towards him and he began to push inside me. His thick cock was oozing precum and I was wondering if he would even fit inside my tight pussy.

On his fourth or fifth stroke, he pushed almost his entire length inside me with force saying he couldn’t wait anymore and it felt painfully good. Attempting to accommodate his wide girth, I spread my legs as wide as I could, relaxing my pussy to help fit his thick cock inside. He was watching his cock pump in and out of me, wrapping my right leg around his waist. He put one arm underneath me, lifting my hips slightly and he finally slid his entire cock inside my stretched cunt. His head rolled back and he moaned.

He slammed into me over and over and I was having a hard time keeping quiet. He wasn’t holding anything back and fucked me with force. We both started to cum and he slammed inside of me one last time before his cock finally softened and slowly slid out of me, some of his cum seeping out soon after. He kissed and licked my nipples briefly and then started to get dressed. I told him he could stay if he wanted but he said no can do, he had assignments to submit.

I walked him to the door, his cum running down my leg and he gave me a peck on the lips. I watched him walk down the hallway until he turned the corner towards the exit. The sun had come up and I had to get ready for class. I had to decide if I wanted to go leaking his cum or clean up first. As an afterthought, I decided to shower remembering that I had dinner plans with Jordan later.

Jordan always kept our conversations relatively deep. He liked to challenge my way of thinking. Often saying things like you’re conditioned to think that way. He was grounded and sure of himself, a free spirit.

He refilled my glass with white wine and leaned over the table and kissed me. His lips were always so soft. I was hoping to feel that softness on pussy after we finished our meal.

For dinner, Jordan roasted a whole chicken that he brushed with garlic butter and paired that with a steamed vegetable medley. He promised dessert later with a sly smile and a wink. My pussy throbbed at the thought. I was itching to get his cock inside of me. I squirmed in my seat creating friction on my clit. I was getting really wet.

We settled on the couch and Jordan looked for something to watch. I wasn’t at all that interested but I waited until he found something. I shivered from the coolness of the room and he put his arm around me. He had selected to watch a documentary about some social crisis in some part of the world. My focus was elsewhere and I decided to drop a hint.

I scooted close to him and swung my leg across his lap. I grabbed his hand and put it between my legs. He groaned and started to rub my pussy. He leaned over and kissed me as he dipped his hand into my panties. He felt my wetness and said I love that your pussy is always wet. I moaned and he kissed and nibbled on my neck as I started to grind on the two fingers he had placed inside me.

Before long his fingers were covered in my juices and I felt the first wave of my orgasm near. He used his thumb to tease and press my clit. My legs started to shake and I dripped all over him. Kissing me he said come here.

I eagerly slipped off my panties and climbed onto his lap. I positioned myself over his cock and looked at him as I began to sank down on it. He moved my hair behind my ear and said you’re so beautiful. He was romantic that way.

My slick pussy made it easy for me to get him inside of me with less than 2 tries. I gasped once I felt his full length inside me, stretching my tight walls around him. He wasn’t quite as thick as Noah but thicker than average. He started to rub my clit again and it sprang me into action. I started bouncing wildly on his cock, leaning on my knees as he spanked my ass. Ride it he whispered. I moaned loudly and began to cum. He laughed asking if that’s all I got. With a hushed voice I said no.

He stood up while holding me, his cock still buried deep in my dripping cunt and carried me toward his room. We passed his roommate’s door first and then we made it to Jordan’s room. He tossed me down on the bed while trying to close the door at the same time but it was still slightly cracked. We were alone so I didn’t mind.

He climbed into bed and licked my freshly fucked pussy. It was still scorching with desire and I wanted his cock back inside me badly. He continued to lick and flick my swollen clit with the tip of his tongue. Fuck me I pleaded. He raised himself onto his knees and told me to suck him.

On all fours, I took him into my mouth, using my lips to create suction. I sucked him deeper into my throat as he took off his shirt. He began to buck his hips into my face as I slowly took him deeper and deeper into my throat. My throat felt tight around his thick, stiff cock. He moaned and slid out of mouth, crawling on the bed to position himself behind me.

I removed my top and braced myself as I felt the tip of his cock at my entrance. He tried to push his full length inside of me but my pussy had already regained its tightness. Slowly, my pussy readjusted and allowed him back in. You’re so fucking tight he moaned. He gave my ass a slap as I felt my walls lock him into place. I looked back at him as he began to pump in and out of me. We established a rhythm and I laid my head on my arms as I enjoyed the rippling sensations cascading over my entire body.

Grabbing me by the waist, he raised me up and put his hand around my neck while his other hand explored my body. I turned my face towards his as we kissed, my head resting on his shoulder. He pulled and pinched my erect nipples before making his way to my swollen clit. I gasped when I felt his fingertips press my button and he sped up his thrusts. I was in a haze and wanted to cum desperately. My pussy throbbing and contracting as he fucked me deeper and deeper. I lost all my senses as multiple waves of orgasms crashed over me.

In my brainless state, I didn’t hear the keys that made a dinging sound as they were dropped onto the kitchen counter or the footsteps coming down the hall. My pussy was stuffed full of cock, my body was vibrating and I was attempting to catch my breath when I heard a voice say well, well, well, what have we here. I thought my mind was playing tricks on me as I saw a silhouette before me. My eyes attempted to adjust to what I was seeing. There, standing in the doorway, was Noah.

(To be continued)

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/nnorcx/caught_between_two_friends