Kate and I have never involved anyone in our play. We talked about it a few times, but that’s all. I’m not sure how she would react to the idea of playing with these two. I’m not even sure if I want that. I probably shouldn’t. They’re both drunk, they’re both inexperienced. Nicky is a virgin. I should just get Kate out of there, walk them home, and that’s it. I’m not sure if they could sneak in without their parents noticing anything, but that’s not my problem.
Once again, I get lost in my own thoughts, staring at Jenny’s puddle, and I’m caught off guard again. Nicky touches my cheek, and as soon as I turn my head, she kisses me. They sneaked out to find some guys, and here I am. The rum that gave courage to Kate did the same to Nicky. I should stop her. She’s clumsy. Is this her first kiss? Did Jenny say anything about this? I can’t remember.
Speaking of Jenny, she should also stop us. Nicky is sliding her hand down my chest, she wants to touch my cock. I really should stop her. But despite her clumsiness, this whole situation is arousing. And not just for me. Jenny won’t stop us because she’s busy. She’s done with the cleaning, and probably went back to the rubbing. She’s trying to be quiet, but I can hear her.
I’m 28, how many chances do I have to score with an 18-year-old? Honestly, I could get a young pussy even in my 40’s. But how about two 18-year-olds? I don’t know. How about a virgin?
I move my hand, but instead of stopping her, I put it between her legs. Maybe this will wake her up. She’s horny, but feeling my hand around her virgin pussy could be too much for her, right?
Apparently, it’s not. She spreads her legs a bit, lets my hand slide on the inner side of her thigh. She unbuttons my pants. She reaches in there, and pulls my cock out. I’m rock hard. Can you blame me? She grabs me, and starts jerking me. I feel the need to return the favor. I want to feel her. I slide my hand inside her shorts, under her panties, and I touch her.
She’s soaked. She grabs my wrist with her other hand as soon as I touch her. She wants me to stop. But she’s still kissing me. She’s still jerking my cock. Her grip even got tighter. And she spreads her legs even more. She moans as I start moving my fingers on her pussy. Grabbing my wrist was an involuntary reaction. She wants this. She’s so eager.
-Oh fuck. – Jenny moans quietly. I can barely hear her words, but those wet sounds are hard not to hear. You know, that sound when a girl is fingering her soaking wet pussy like crazy because she’s about to cum. We kind of left her out of the action, but she didn’t care. She found her own way to get involved, and she doesn’t stop here.
She kneels down in front of me, and puts her lips around my cock. Nicky doesn’t seem to mind, her hand can’t cover me fully anyways. They quickly develop their cock-jerking-sucking synergy, they find the right rhythm, and honestly they make me lose my mind.
I didn’t want any of this. I’m not saying that I would have said no, I’m not crazy. But this wasn’t my plan. I just wanted to keep them away from Kate’s definitely-not-hidden hiding place. And now, all of our primary private parts have been touched. Jenny’s by her own hands. Nicky’s by mine. Mine by Nicky’s hand and Jenny’s mouth. I’m not complaining, I just want to be clear. When I gave them that bottle of rum, I didn’t expect things to go this direction.
But now, let’s just enjoy this. Nicky is already squirming. If I keep rubbing her clit like this, she’s just going to cum. And why would I stop? They are going to make me cum as well. Jenny uses her mouth surprisingly well, or maybe just the situation itself turns me on so much. It doesn’t matter. Nicky finally pulls away from my lips, this kiss felt like an eternity. She needs to practice. A lot. But it was nice overall. And really sloppy.
-Don’t stop, please don’t stop – that’s all she can say, and her body starts to tremble. Her moans make it impossible to hold back anymore. My cock explodes inside Jenny’s mouth. I usually have a lot of cum, but it doesn’t feel like an explosion. The range, the speed, the intensity of my cumshot isn’t too high. But now, it feels like it’s just going to shoot right through Jenny. People are going to find her here in the morning with numerous gunshot wounds caused by a lethal cumshot. She looks up at me. Her eyes tell me it’s a lot, she’s struggling, but she’s gonna make it. I fill her mouth completely. She doesn’t swallow. I know it’s a lot, but I’m not going to let her spit it out.
-Swallow it! – I tell her. She pulls back keeping all of my cum in her mouth, looks at me and shakes her head slowly. She looks so cute and innocent.
I pull my hand out of Nicky’s shorts. My fingers are soaked. I want to slap her. Sure, she’s young. Maybe this is the first time someone came in her mouth. Who cares? She shouldn’t let it go to waste. But she’s not my sub. Slapping her would be wrong. Also, that would make her spit most of the cum out.
Jenny stands up. There’s some cum on her cheek, but she managed to keep most of it inside her mouth. She leans to Nicky. Her girlfriend knows exactly why. They kiss, and divide it equally. I guess. They both swallow it and smile at each other. Jenny comes back to me, and gets back to my cock to finish the cleaning. I underestimated them.
-It tastes good – Nicky smiles at me. As soon as I look at her, she blushes and looks down for a moment. But down there, all she can see is her childhood bff sucking the last drops of cum out of my cock. Probably the innocent, shy, virgin side of her realizes what just happened. She looks in my eyes again. I see no signs of regret. I smile at her and kiss her on the lips. She kisses back. She still wants me.
It feels so nice. Her second kiss feels so much better than the first one, and it’s a great sign as well. Yes, she’s still drunk and probably still horny, but she’s out of that sex-crazed zone. The sexual tension is still there between the three of us, but it’s not that strong anymore. We all came, we all calmed down, but if I don’t want another storm after the calm, I need to stop them. For now. I wouldn’t mind another storm, but there’s something I need to do before that. It’s time to rescue Kate.
I stop them both. I tell Jenny to get dressed. She puts her panties on without even thinking about it. They look damp, but she doesn’t mind it at all. I stand up and Nicky does the same immediately. I don’t even have time to move, she grabs my cock and puts it back to where it belongs. She buttons my pants. She looks at me, and there’s something in her eyes that’s hard to resist. She’s obviously not in love with me, but maybe she thinks so. She’s young, inexperienced and naive. I gave her an experience she’s never had before.
Again, I don’t want to complain, but what the hell am I supposed to do in a situation like this? Her adoration makes me feel superior. Kate loves me, but she’s not this enthusiastic. Maybe she was at the very start, but not anymore. Should I really take this opportunity to be the first guy to fuck Nicky, and don’t care about her possible feelings? Should I offer her the choice and trust her to make a wise decision?
-Do you want my cock inside you? – I ask them. I wasn’t done thinking about it, but somehow the question just slipped out. Jenny nods without hesitation. Nicky just stares at me for a few seconds. For her, it’s not that easy. She takes a deep breath, bites her lips, and nods as well. I tell them to follow me.
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/mx5r2q/the_best_worst_idea_of_my_life_part_3_mfff_bdsm
Must have part 4!!!!!