[MFF] They called it “Torture Time”, it was anything but torture

I was so inexperienced at the time that the thought of being with two girls at once had never even crossed my mind. It was the early 90s and a much more innocent time before the invention internet porn. I was still jerking off to the lingerie catalog from Sears or a playboy when I was lucky enough to get my hands on one. I was so happy one girl was willing to have sex with me and I wasn’t sure anyone else ever would again.

It was the summer after we graduated high school and my girlfriend Emma (name changed) had decided to take our relationship to the next level and we had sex for the first time the night after graduation and the following weeks consisted of having sex all day while her parents were at work. It was that exciting kind of sex where everything is new and awkward. You’re exploring and learning and you never really get to have that feeling again. All these years later I still look back on that fondly.

About three weeks into July Emma called me early one morning and said she couldn’t hang out. Her best friend Amanda had been dumped by her boyfriend and needed to hang out. I completely understood and figured I’d catch up with my own friends who I’d barely seen since graduation. This happened for a few more days, which was also understandable, but on maybe the forth day Emma said she missed me and invited me to come hang out with the two of them. We could watch movies or whatever.

When we got to Amanda’s house I immediately noticed how hot she was. Long dirty blonde hair hung down her back in disarray, her long alabaster legs barely hidden by a pair of short lace pajama shorts and a t-shirt that almost made it look like she wasn’t wearing anything else. She wasn’t wearing any shoes or socks and I took notice of her cute pedicured toes. (I was beginning to develop a foot fetish at this time after an experience the first time I had sex, but that’s a story for another time). Her nose and eyes were red and she’d clearly been crying, but the vulnerability only made her more beautiful.

When Emma introduced us she gave me a warm hug and rested her head on my chest. I wasn’t prepared for this level of intimate contact and it was all I could do to pull my croch away so she wouldn’t feel my cock swelling in my pants.

The next hour or so was me sitting supportively on the sidelines as the two ladies discussed what a jerk Brian (Amanda’s ex) was and how it was his loss and how much Amanda hated boys (always followed by a “No offense Mark”). Honestly I feeling awkward and was looking for an excuse to leave when Amanda’s mom came through the living room and said she’d be gone for a few hours. She left money for a pizza and told us the movie she rented was still in the VCR if we wanted to watch it.

Amanda got up to turn on the movie and Emma asked for a blanket because she was chilly. Amanda went into another room to retrieve the blanket and Emma caught me sneaking a glance at her ass as he walked away.

“Omg, she’s my best friend! You were checking out her ass!” She said

I was flustered and could feel the blood rushing to my face in embarrassment. “I…I was not! I just happened to look in that direction!” Was the best defense I could come up with. Luckily she laughed it off and said my embarrassment was adorable. When Amanda came back Emma said “Mark thinks you have a nice ass” and gave her ass a little smack as she walked by. This set off giggling and playful wrestling between the two of them as they tried to smack each other on the ass.

“OH. MY. GOD!” Amanda screeched and pointed at me “Your boyfriend has a boner!”

This was a humiliating nightmare. I guess I had been turned on watching them roll around with each other and gotten hard without realizing. I quickly put a throw pillow on my lap and exclaimed “No I don’t!”

“Yes he does! Move the pillow!” She said between laughter.

“Move the pillow Mark! Right now!” Emma said. I expected more anger but she mostly stifling laughter.

I refused to budge. The only problem is it wouldn’t go down. I tried everything but my cock continued to throb in my pants. I really don’t know how my face could be so red with embarrassment and still have enough blood to fill my raging out of control hard on, but it happened.

Without warning Emma made a jump for the pillow and managed to get behind me and pull both the pillow and my arms above my head and force me down onto my back on the couch. Before I could fight back she sat on my arms and pinned them above my head. Then she calmly pointed to my cock and said “Did you get hard from looking at my best friend Mark?”

“No! I wouldn’t do that!” I said in a shakey voice.

She gave me a not so gentle slap on the face and said “Don’t lie to me, you’ve been a dirty little boy haven’t you?”

“I’m sorry, I didn’t meant to, it just happened.” I said.

With that the girls whispered in each other’s ear for a minute and started giggling.

“You need to be punished for this, so now you’re going to have to have some ‘torture time'” Emma said, “we’re going to sit on you and make out with each other. You aren’t allowed to do anything but lay there and watch. Do you understand? this is your punishment”

I should be clear that I could easily stand up and over power them and get away, but I definitely did not want to. However they seemed to be getting off on the idea that they were teaching me a lesson, so I pretended to resist put of fear if I acted into it they’d stop.

I’ve never been so horny in my life since those moments. Amanda moved onto my lap and removed her Tshirt to reveal her perfect breasts and no bra. My mouth watered at the thought of taking her erect pink nipples into my mouth. Emma removed her shirt and bra, then reached out to begin making out with Amanda and softly caressing her nipple with her thumb. Amanda started to grind on my cock through my pants and I was afraid I’d cum in my pants immediately. I opened my mouth to say something but Emma shifted herself from sitting in my arms to sitting directly on my mouth. I tried to speak but my words were inaudible and this made them both laugh, Which only made me harder if I’m being honest.

Emma stood up and looked me in the eyes “I’m going to show the proper way to eat my pussy. I want you stick out your tongue and stay completely still. Don’t try to lick or wiggle your tongue. Do you under stand?” I said yes and removed the white cotton panties shed been wearing under her skirt and positioned her pussy directly over my open mouth. I loved the way she tasted. I used to wish I could by candy that tasted as good as her pussy. She began grinding herself on my tongue and open mouth. Slow at first then increasingly faster until she was moaning. I could only breath quickly through my nose when she rocked away, but then covered my nose again with her asshole. All the while she kissed Amanda who was still dry humping my lower half.

I could feel Emma’s pussy start to pulsate and completely without warning my mouth filled with what I thought at the time was pee. My only choice was to swallow or choke and I chose to swallow. Emma was shaking and moaning above me and still spraying onto my chest (It would be almost 5 years before I learned what squirting was). When she was done she collapsed back onto the sofa still quietly moaning with pleasure and playing with my hair. I know she did all the work but being the instrument of her pleasure made me feel so good.

“Your turn she said to Amanda” who then stood up and began pulling down her lacy pajama shorts to reveal her completely shaved pussy.

“Wait, wait, wait!” I said “I don’t want to cheat on you babe” I said to Emma. She laughed and pushed my head back down onto the couch. “Its not cheating if I’m here with you and telling you to do it. Mandy is my best friend and she needs to get her mind off things. I would do it for one of your friends of you asked me to. (And before the end of the summer she would, and so would I)”

Amanda took her seat on my mouth only she faced the opposite direction so that as she fucked my mouth I could look up and watch her rub her tits and see Emma rubbing her own. When she finally came it was nothing as extraordinary as what happened with Emma, but I think I got the job done.

Amanda stood up and walked over to sit in Emma’s Lap. The two kissed and caressed each other. I was still rock hard and said half joking “Do I get a turn?” And they looked at me, then back at each other, and they both started cracking up laughing. “This is torture time, you were being punished. We’re not going to reward you” Emma said. Then with a rascally smile she added “I guess you can strip down and jerk off. Put on a show for us”

I was only 18 and still not really comfortable with my naked body, but I was so horny I did what she said. I stripped off my clothes and laid back on the couch and began to stroke my cock. The two girls watched me with intensity as they embraced each other. I felt a finger trace its way down my thigh and come to rest gently on my asshole. Then she slowly began working the finger inside of me. I wanted to say stop, back then putting anything in your asshole was “gay” and forbidden, but it felt so good I let her continue. She worked the finger inside of me and began moving it up and down in such away I started to cum explosively and almost instantly. The orgasm rocked my entire body and I could feel my legs cramping and my toes curling. I had never cum like that before. There was so much cum

Emma stood up and came to kneel next to my head. She looked at me and stroked my hair before bending down to lick the cum up off my stomach. She then brought her face up to mine and started to kiss me. I was initially repulsed as I realized she was forcing my own cum back into my mouth, but it quickly turned back into arousal. I was already getting hard again. She stopped kissing me and whispered into my ear “Good boy” then licked my ear.

She stood up and said “clean yourself up, were going to order pizza”

I did as instructed and three of us spent the rest of the day cuddling, eating pizza and watching Interview with a Vampire.

This was just the beginning of a life long journey into exploring kink and sexuality, and to this day whenever someone says I’m a “good boy” I get a little bit hard.

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/m4wbzm/mff_they_called_it_torture_time_it_was_anything