Never Have I Ever

Wrote this in notes on mobile. Hopefully the formatting isn’t jacked up. (Bi & straight)

Melissa & Josh had become a thing after their cabin encounter. He broke it off with his girlfriend and he and Melissa were inseparable. They were dancing around the idea of moving in together but both still wanted their autonomy, keep some mystery in the relationship. However, their excursions to the cabin became more frequent. Often, some of the other couples joined them. It was a good escape, to just hang out together, smoke & drink a little to relax and get away from the hassles that came with every day life in the city.

Cory & Tabitha had joined them this particular weekend, along with Damien and Tristan. They were all in their middle 30’s, fairly diverse in their opinions about everything so conversation was always interesting. Especially with a lowered filter. Tonight, however, Tabitha had a different idea…a game. Tabitha was a gorgeous Korean-black woman. Slender, with a fantastic head of black curls that streamed down her back. She was rather exotic looking. But she was ridiculously down to earth, playful, downright ornery at times. How she got Cory mystified everyone. He was pretty ordinary, had been losing his hair since his junior year so he just did away with it. He was a bit of a nerd, as a computer engineer, most of his contributions regarding his professional life went over their heads or were just uninteresting. Still a good guy, and Tabitha brought him out of his shell. He could almost be considered extroverted around her.

Tabitha broke out a new bottle of Barefoot Pinot and dimmed the lights. Instructing everyone to sit in a circle, she said is anyone familiar to Never Have I Ever? Melissa gave a derisive snort & said you mean the Gen X answer to spin the bottle? Tabitha gave her a side eye, and said yes… but I think it should be interesting.

She had already prepared for it, had her questions written out on neatly folded, bright pieces of paper. She was a fan of Bujo so she had gotten creative with them. Cory & Josh, being guys, just shrugged & joined the girls on the floor. Tab had an ulterior motive though. She knew Cory was bi-curious & found Damien attractive. She also knew Damien was bi & he had an open relationship with Tristan. They had chatted online many times and delved into relationship issues, especially once she learned about Cory’s proclivities.

They decided Tristan should go first, since he was the newest member of the group. His chit said “had an orgasm from oral sex”. Everyone laughed a bit & drank. Except for Melissa. Feeling everyone’s eyes on her, she was like “What? It feels good but I’d rather be doing other things. Anyway, ever since I bought the Satisfyer, I doubt any of you boys could compare.” They all rolled their eyes. Tabitha inwardly agreed though. That thing is fucking fantastic. She looked a little forward to her solo date nights. Sometimes BOB’s just can’t be beat.

So, since Melissa had “failed” the last draw, it was her turn. It went like this for a while until Cory drew “had a sexual encounter with a member of the same sex”. He laughed & said no way but he felt a stiffening in his cock. Tristan said it’s ok, I’ll get you through this one. Cory said, no homo though, right? It’s a game, right. Tristan assured him it was a game & led him to the bedroom. As he passed Tabitha, he gave her a scritch on the head like she was a good pup.

The remaining five continued playing but eventually reached things they had all done & were getting a bit hammered. Melissa & Josh called it a night. Tabitha & Damien thought their partners had been gone for quite a bit and decided to go check on them.

They walked into the room, finding Cory laying on his back while Tristan sucked his cock. He was oblivious to the intrusion. Damien & Tab hung back until the experiment reached his conclusion. Tabitha had been watching Cory all along, and the display had turned her on incredibly. She walked over to the bed to observe Cory in his post orgasmic euphoria. Although Damien considered himself bi, and had intercourse with women, he had never gone down on one. He got on the bed with Cory & Tristan, and pulled Tabitha over to his side, & took off her pants and panties. He told her the game had sparked a curiousity but he needed some help. He asked if she would teach him how to eat pussy. She had never been asked for guidance before but said she would do her best. She had read a book about how to be a better lesbian: for men. Maybe it would give her some confidence.

As she took off her top & bra, she laid back with her knees up & invited Damien into them. He had a general idea of how to get started. Head is head, right? He started at her feet, working up her legs with gentle licks and nibbles. He then trailed his tongue along the crease of her leg & hip, licking along the line where her panties had been moments before. She tasted a bit spicy, musky. He imagined that flavour only intensified as he got closer to her clit and pussy.

He licked a finger, generously lubing it with his saliva. He touched her clit gently, then ran it down the cleft between her lips, pausing to probe the soft & mysterious flesh. It felt extremely similar to what he was used to, except more pliable, more textured. Continuing to explore, he moved his finger to her ass. Reflexively, she raised her ass to allow more access. Familiar territory, something that both genders can experience pleasure from. He gently slid his finger in, just slightly. She moaned, but said in a stern teacher-ish tone to get back to the lesson, focus on your work. “Yes, ma’am “ he said sheepishly, “I forgot my Ritalin today”. She giggled.

Cory & Tristan, who had been observing after their encounter (but only after having reciprocated to Tristan, having had his own lesson in fellatio), decided to help Damien out. Cory began kissing & sucking Tabitha’s breasts, kneading them as a kitten to its mother. She loved rough play with her tits. They were small, but firm with aereolas about the size of quarters & nipples that were small pebbles of cappuccino colored flesh, slightly lighter than that of her aereolas. Her heritage gave her an almost indescribable color but it always sparked hunger & lust.

Tristan, having had a little more experience with the nether regions of women took over as instructor for a moment. He parted Tabithas lips with a finger from each hand so Damien would have more room to explore. They looked at each other & kissed. Tristan pulled away & said you heard the lady, get to work.

Damien began licking her clit with the firm tip of her tongue & she squirmed in response & let out a sharp breathe. Taking this as approval, he continued to do this. After a minute or two, she whispered to him to use his tongue as a cock to fuck her pussy. He did as he was told & she moaned her approval. Tabitha then directed to replace his tongue with two fingers and to start licking her clit again, & to alternate swirling his tongue on & around it, almost as if he were writing with it. Imagine your tongue is a pen & you are writing in cursive. Thankfully they were all old enough to remember how.

Seeing that this was going to be a joint effort, especially if they want to beat the Satisfyer, Tristan looped an arm between her legs & slipped a finger into her ass. He leisurely finger fucked her ass, deeply & firmly. Damien was diligently working her clit, tasting her wetness. It was slightly salty, smelled incredibly sexy. He too was finger fucking her vag. Cory had moved from her breasts, kissing & sucking every inch of skin he could reach. He had gotten hard again & Tabitha had noticed. She pulled him to her face, grasping his cock. She guided it to her mouth & used her hand on his ass to thrust him. Before he could cum, Damien & Tristan accomplished their mission, and she had a tremendous orgasm. They high fived each other & Damien said fuck Satisfyer. Tabitha heard this & replied to their naked backsides as they were leaving, “ but it STILL took the both of you to accomplish the task of a battery operated toy”. They laughed & said whatever & went to their room to tend to each other.

Tabitha was not done though. She wanted Corys cum in her, now. She pushed him onto his back & lowered herself onto his cock. She teasingly rode the tip, then sliding down it, like a stripper on a pole, her clit grinding against his shaft. As she could tell he was on the precipice of cumming, she enveloped his cock with her tight, dripping pussy. Just in time to capture his jet of cum. She collapsed onto the bed, & they both lay there in exhausted silence. After a few minutes, Cory wondered aloud what are Josh & Mel doing. The only response Tabitha could think of was Fuck em. They looked at each other & started laughing. Then Tab said I need a fucking shower & got out of bed to make her way to the bathroom. Cory watched her glorious nude body retreat & said I’ll be there… soon.

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/jqnz42/never_have_i_ever