[21F]ingered by a Friend[23M] and more, part 3

I laughed at Ben and gave him a shove as I hopped off of him and ran over to Ryan’s bathroom. I peeled off the fishnets and turned on the water in the shower to let it heat up. Ryan’s en-suite didn’t have a full bathtub, but it had a walk in shower big enough to have some fun in. The built-in bench on one side had proven to be very useful over the last year.

I stepped into the shower as I heard the bathroom door creak open behind me. I was hoping Ben would reconsider his decision to stay clothed because I really wanted him to join me, but I didn’t turn around to look right away – instead letting the shower run over my body, slicking my hair back and humming to myself. Tonight had been more than I’d bargained for in the best ways possible, but a part of me felt a little anxious about what all this would mean in the morning. Ryan and Ben had clearly talked about this at least once, but, I had no clue what to think about that. I’d never done anything like this before – just thinking about telling Ryan about my night made me wet and anxious all at once. I didn’t think he’d be upset, he was protective but not in a manipulative way. I knew this wasn’t a “test” of some sort, but still, it was unfamiliar territory.

“Hey in there,” Ben tapped on the glass wall of the shower, “please look at me. What’cha thinking about?”
I turned around and gave him a small smile, noticing he’d already discarded his shirt before coming in the bathroom. He kept his gaze on my eyes and I wished he would take all of me in at least one more time, but the look on his face was so tender, I melted.

“Are you gonna join me in here, or do I have to take a lonely shower just because you won’t let me get your pants off?” I teased him.

Relief washed over his face and he started unbuttoning his pants, “I didn’t want to get in there without an invitation,” he admitted, “you haven’t started regretting anything, have you?” Ben opened the shower door and stepped in slowly. I took in the sight of him, he was still rock hard and just as thick as his video had made him look. He kissed my forehead gently and hugged me to him, pressing his cock into my belly and making my knees weak.

“Definitely no regrets from me,” I returned the hug and tilted my face up to kiss him in return. He moaned and I felt my nipples harden against his bare skin. He started rubbing my back, pressing us together even closer. I tried to reach down to stroke him, but he stopped me, “I truly meant it when I said I didn’t expect anything in return. I promised Ryan that would be up to you. You don’t owe me this.” I looked up at him and smirked, “What if I said *you* owed *me* this?” He opened his mouth to say something, but stopped and rolled his eyes back as I grasped his dick at the base. Ben braced himself against the wall and stuttered, “Yeah… ah… y-yeah, ok. Yes.” I felt so powerful right then.

I trailed my other hand down his chest, and perched myself on the bench so I was eye level with his member. Stroking him slowly as the water was hitting his back and spraying a mist over me, I looked up to see his eyes were squeezed shut and his breathing was ragged. Slowly, he looked down to watch me and I leaned closer to take his head into my mouth, maintaining eye contact. He held his breath and pushed my hair away so it was slicked back again, “Oh god, careful. I’ve been on edge since we left the bar and am ready to blow.” I released him with a pop to flash a wicked smile, “Good, I cannot wait to taste what you can give me.”
“Fuck, sweetheart. You are so hot.”

With that, I eased him back into my mouth, bobbing down to take more of him little by little. He was thick enough that I had to be very careful not to let my teeth get in the way. Finally, I got him all the way inside and he was hitting the back of my throat. Ben was trying so hard to stay still and let me keep control, watching me with awe.

“I’m, so close, please. A little rougher before I explode,” he whispered. I’d barely heard him over the water, but in response, I placed his hand in my hair – making him grab a handful. Then I placed both my hands on his ass and started pushing him into my mouth, showing him he could take control if he wanted. That’s all he needed. His grip in my hair tightened and he fucked my mouth, growling while slamming into my throat and releasing more cum than I’d swallowed in a long time.

When he released his grip on my hair, he slumped a bit against the wall. I licked my lips and motioned for him to trade places with me. Once he sat down on the bench, I straddled his lap and grabbed the shampoo to wash our hair. Ben looked dazed, but started playing with my nipples.

Before I could flick the cap of the shampoo bottle open, I noticed movement in the corner of my eye and turned my head towards the door. Ryan was standing just outside the bathroom, stroking himself while watching us. I didn’t think Ben had seen him yet; Ben’s eyes were closed, sucking gently on my nipple.

I blew a kiss at Ryan and he smiled back at me and called out, “You got room in there for me, too?”

Ben startled, and wrapped an arm around me, “Nah, dude. Wait your turn.”

I pouted at Ben, but I wanted to laugh. The shower was big, but it wasn’t three people big. Ryan couldn’t have gotten in here with room to do anything even if Ben had been okay with it. Ben turned his gaze back to me and said, too quietly for Ryan to hear, “Why does time move so quickly with you?” and brought my face down to his for a deep kiss. I heard Ryan grunt from the doorway, so I rocked my hips against Ben to give him more of a show.

Ben knew what I was doing, so he stood up, keeping me straddled around him, and pinned me against the glass wall between us and Ryan. This gave Ryan the view of my ass smooshed against the glass, watching Ben press against me. Ben was semi hard against my folds, but I could tell he was feeling over-sensitive and protecting himself from friction. He was doing this to get a rise out of Ryan, not really to start anything with me again.

Or so I thought, as he separated his hips from mine to let one of his fingers enter into me. I gripped onto Ben’s shoulders, afraid of being dropped in the slippery shower. Ben buried his face into my neck and worked me up to the edge of another orgasm with his fingers quickly. I heard Ryan cumming behind me. Ben nipped my ear, “Your boyfriend’s too noisy. Let me hear you scream.”

He pushed his fingers all the way into me and I was lost all over again. This orgasm was fast, but intense. I called out Ben’s name and moaned, digging my nails into his shoulders and shuddering. Suddenly, the shower door opened next to us and Ben leaned me away from the wall. A soft towel was wrapped around me and Ben begrudgingly let Ryan carry me out of the shower and place me on the bed.

Ryan smiled at me, using the towel to gently dry me off. He kissed the tip of my nose and asked, “How much fun did you have tonight?”

“Mmm, so much,” I murmured. Exhaustion hit me like a brick wall. Josh crept into bed to spoon me and asked, “How much do you love me for setting this up?” “Oh god, so, so much,” I breathed. “And you’ll tell me all about it in the morning?” Ryan confirmed. I nodded. He grabbed the makeup wipes I had in his nightstand and carefully cleaned up my mascara and eyeliner that I was sure the shower adventure had turned into a smudgy mess.

A now fully clothed but somewhat damp and disheveled Ben appeared next to my face, “Sleep well, gorgeous.” He kissed my cheek before addressing Ryan, “Later, man.” Ben slipped out of the bedroom as I fell asleep in Ryan’s arms.

That’s the end of my first experience being shared! It literally could not have been a better first time imho. :)

Thank you for reading the whole thing, I hope you enjoyed it as much as I just enjoyed reliving it. <3

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/jgbdcz/21fingered_by_a_friend23m_and_more_part_3