Sam looked between us, “You’re boning your sister?” he asked Ari.
“No,” Ari said, “would you put your dick away, please?”
I was looking him over, he wasn’t as big as Ari was, but he was circumcised and I was curious about the difference there as Ari’s cock was a bit musky around the head due to his foreskin. “I don’t mind,” I said as I looked up to Ari.
A flash of anger came across his face but he nodded at Sam, “Whatever, just don’t get her pregnant,” and stormed off to his bedroom.
Sam hadn’t seen Ari’s cock, so he didn’t know he wasn’t really in the same league. I’d seen porn stars bigger than both of them though, so I don’t think either one was on the upper level of things, maybe average to a bit above average, but I wasn’t exactly experienced with measurement beyond my hand to their dick size. I had small, thin, hands so everything looked bigger in them.
I moved over to Sam and he looked back towards my brother’s room, “Is he going to deck me if I let you touch me?” he asked.
I shook my head, “Not unless you don’t stop if I ask you to.”
He backed up a little on the couch but groaned as I wrapped my fingers around his cock and started stroking him slowly, “Want to tell me what I was watching?” he asked. His body was tense and he was still glancing back to my brother’s room. Expecting him to storm out and beat the shit out of his only remaining friend, I suppose.
I smiled slightly and stopped stroking him long enough to pull my panties off of me, his eyes were on Ari’s door and I climbed up on his lap. He groaned as he felt the tip of his cock rubbing back and forth against my clit and looked back at me, “Zia…I don’t…”
I kissed him and pulled his hands up to me, they grasped my ass and squeezed as I lowered myself down along the side of his cock, riding him without letting him inside of me. He pulled me tighter to him and I could feel every vein in his cock as he pulled me along his shaft. “Why are you doing this?” he asked me, his hand in my hair at the back of my head, pulling me away slightly so he could speak instead of kissing me.
I looked to Ari’s door, “Because you chose him over Christian,” I said.
He furrowed his brow, his other hand slid up my lower back, holding me down more firmly against his cock as I continued to grind on him in slow, steady movements, “Regret would have been a blush and avoiding eye contact, not tripping over yourself trying to back away from someone. I couldn’t choose him after seeing that and you don’t owe me shit for it.”
I bit my lower lip and tilted my head as he pulled my hair a little harder, his dick was throbbing beneath me, “I’ve kind of fucked up my brother’s life every which way. He hasn’t dated anyone in four years because girls get jealous of me, even knowing I’m his little sister…”
Sam groaned and laughed slightly, “From what I saw they have reason to be jealous,” he said.
I stopped moving and he looked at me, “They really don’t. He doesn’t want me that way, he just…humors me,” I said, my eyes roaming towards my brother’s bedroom door.
I looked down at Sam, he was an attractive guy, shoulder-length dark hair, deep olive toned skin with sharp features and grey eyes. He had Greek lineage, I think, though I believe his mom was French. “So, you’re not fucking your brother then?” he asked.
I shook my head and resumed rubbing myself against Sam’s cock, “No,” I said dismissively, “tonight was the first time he’s touched me in over a week,” I laughed lightly and looked at him, “I can seduce pretty much anyone except the person I want,” I said sadly.
“He’s your brother, Z. You can’t fault him for not wanting to fuck you,” he offered.
“He’s not really my brother, though. Technically we’re distant cousins. His mom adopted me when my mom…couldn’t deal with having a kid.”
“You’re still blood related?” he groaned.
I nodded, “Distantly. We have the same great great great grandparent or something like that. Legally we could get married, so I don’t see why we couldn’t fuck,” I said.
“Does he know you’re not really siblings?” Sam asked.
“Yeah, we found out when our…his…mom died. I wasn’t his problem to take on and he still did because it’s what his mom wanted,” I reached up and wiped my eyes as I looked back down to Sam, “I’ve ruined my brother’s life and cost him three of his closest friends. He’d be better off…”
I climbed off of Sam’s lap and started stroking him with my hand. His cock was soaked in my fluids and he groaned loudly as I massaged his balls and curled my hand up his cock. I got him off almost mechanically, but he didn’t seem to mind that my heart wasn’t really in it. “Do you think you could get him to makeup with Christian and the others if I weren’t around?” I asked.
He shook his head, “You’re the only one I’ve ever seen talk Ari into doing anything he didn’t want to do. At best, I give approval to what he wants and he’ll sometimes go for it. What do you mean by if you weren’t around?” he asked.
I shrugged, “He deserves a good life and me hanging around is causing him nothing but grief, Sam.”
“You disappearing would kill him, Z,” he said as he reached over and stroked my cheek.
I grabbed a few tissues and started cleaning the cum from his cock and stomach, he put his cock away and zipped up his pants, “He would get over it eventually,” I said.
Sam picked me up and threw me over his shoulder and I screamed, “Sam! Put me down!”
He carried me over towards Ari’s bedroom as Ari opened the door to see what was going on. Sam pushed past him and carried me into the room, dropping me onto the bed before turning back to Ari, “She told me everything, you pervert. You’re fucking your own sister?”
Ari got flustered and before I could say anything to let him know I did not, in fact, tell Sam anything, Ari closed his bedroom door and sat on the floor, crying, “Once…I fucked her once…”
“Holy shit, I didn’t think that’d work,” Sam said as he smirked.
I sat up on the bed and looked over to Ari, “I didn’t tell him that!” I said.
Sam knelt down by Ari and rubbed his shoulder, “She’s not even your sister, right?” he asked.
Ari shook his head, “Not by blood.”
“Then what the fuck is keeping you from fucking her? Are you not attracted to her?” Sam asked.
Ari looked at Sam, “I promised my mom I’d keep her safe,” he said.
“My dude, there are a lot of sketchy assholes out there, present company included. On *your* cock is probably the safest place for her to be, sexually speaking.”
“Why are you advocating for this?” I asked him.
“I want more than a half-assed hand job,” Sam said as he smiled at me.
He turned back to Ari and put his hand under my brother’s chin, lifting his head so he was looking into Ari’s eyes, “I want to watch you two together, and I might want to join in, if you’ll let me?”
Ari looked from Sam to me, then back to Sam, “No one can know about this,” he said.
Sam nodded, “Obviously.”
“What do you want us to do?” I asked as Ari got up from the floor while wiping his eyes.
“Give in to everything you both want from each other…,” Sam said as he dragged a chair from the corner of Ari’s room and moved it closer to the bed. He reached out to me and touched my bare pussy, “How have you managed to say no to her at all?” he asked my brother quietly.
Ari blushed, “I do the laundry…”
I gasped and looked at Ari, “Seriously? I just had to stop wearing panties?”
He blushed brighter and gathered my hair pulling it all over my right shoulder as he kissed and bit my neck on the left side, “I’ve also been watching you sleep and just jacking off a lot,” he whispered.
Ari stood behind me and I moaned as his hands moved under my shirt and over my stomach. He pulled my body back to his and I looked at Sam, a big smile on his face as he watched Ari let go of his fears surrounding having me. My brother pulled my hair and groped my breasts, he was still dressed but I could feel his dick through the jeans he wore.
I turned my head towards him and put his hand on the side of my face, holding me to him as he kissed me deeply. A wanton moan escaped both of us. Ari lifted my t-shirt off of me, quickly throwing it to the floor as he grasped my body. He turned my head back to face Sam and spread my legs a bit. His hand rubbed between my legs until thick drips of fluid fell to the bed below me and I arched my back in intense pleasure.
His touch had me close to cumming without ever sticking his dick in me. Just kissing my neck, pulling my hair, and rubbing my thighs and pussy. Not even fingering me, just his hand on me. He put my hands on the post at the end of his bed and pulled me slightly, bending my lower body until my hips were tipped and he could push into me from behind. I didn’t even realize he’d pulled his cock out.
I moaned loudly and leaned forward as he thrust into me. Sam had his cock out again, biting his lower lip and stroking himself as he watched Ari make me tremble with each thrust. Ari bit my neck and I cried out loudly, arching myself and allowing him to fuck me deeper as he pulled my hair and dipped his fingers down between my legs, rubbing my aching clit as he hit that sensitive tingly spot inside of me.
Ari moaned as my body tensed. His lips were right by my ear, “Sam, she’s about to cum on my cock, do you want a taste of her?”
Sam got up and bent over the foot of the bed. His lips closed over my clit and I whimpered. Ari’s hands moved to my throat and hip. He was fucking me hard from behind and Sam’s lips and tongue made me want to squirm, but it just made my brother’s grip on me tighten a little more.
I cried as I came. Sam drank up the sprayed fluid and Ari soothed my body, easing it down from the intensity of the orgasm. He whispered in my ear, “I can do what I want, right, baby sister?” he asked in a faint, needy breath.
I nodded.
Ari pushed Sam away from me and leaned me forward on my hands and knees then looked to Sam, “Kiss her and play with her tits, would ya?” he asked as he thrust hard and deep into me.
Sam lifted my chin and kissed me hard. My tits hung slightly in this position and Sam groped and squeezed them as Ari thrust deeper, evoking a gasping whimper from me as my body tensed in another orgasm. Then I felt my brother grab my shoulders and thrust upwards, lifting me off of the bed slightly as he rocked his hips tightly against me, a warmth flowed through me and I had tears flowing down my cheeks as I started to come down from the second orgasm. After a few minutes of kissing my neck and keeping himself impaled in my flooded cunt, he pulled free of me and turned me around to face him and guided me to clean his softening cock of our fluids.
Ari held my pussy open for his friend to see his cum dripping from me, “Zia, can Sam have you now?” he asked, not breaking eye contact with his friend.
I started to pull my lips from his cock to approve, but he pulled my head further down on him, making me gag and my cunt and ass both contract while Sam watched. Sam didn’t hesitate as Ari smiled and said, “She said yes.”
I smiled with my brother’s dick in my mouth and Sam pushed his cock into my messy cunt, squelching as he went as deep as he could. Ari let my head go and lifted my chin up so he could kiss me, “Our beautiful baby sister just looks so happy right now, doesn’t she Sam?” he said, not shifting his eyes from mine.
Sam grunted and Ari pulled me away from his friend’s cock, “Climb on the bed and lay down,” He said as he glanced to Sam.
Ari shoved his own cock back into my pussy a few times then he sat me on his friends lap, his dick sliding easily into me, and looked at Sam, “Play with her clit so she stays relaxed,” he said, kissing my neck and smiling as he rubbed his dick around my asshole.
I turned to look at him and he leaned down, “Anything I want, right?”
I nodded and Ari pushed gently at my hole. I winced, but tried to remain relaxed. Ari pulled my hair hard as he pushed the head of his cock into me. I whined. Sam was distracted as he watched my face contort, shifting between pain and pleasure. He knew Ari was pushing into my ass. He reached back and grabbed my ass cheeks and spread them for my brother. I fell forward, my hands on Sam’s shoulders as Ari worked himself halfway into me. I winced and moaned and moved my hips back and down towards both of them.
“That’s it baby sister,” Ari growled at me, “Let your brothers have your body.”
Sam closed his eyes, he was trying to concentrate on something else as Ari’s continued suggestion of him being my brother too, nearly sent him into his climax. I hadn’t said anything during this. I was mostly just whimpering and moaning as my body became overwhelmed with sensations.
I rolled my hips as I came down and pushed back against them and both of them moved to grab my hips, Ari relented and let Sam have them to guide. Ari grabbed my tits instead, squeezing and fondling me as they fucked me together. Sam was trying to pull out of me but Ari held me down on him, bouncing me on Sam’s cock until he came in me, though his cum wasn’t nearly as deep as Ari’s.
Then Ari lifted me from Sam’s cock and looked at Sam as a mix of their cum dripped from me and back down onto Sam’s lap. Ari looked at Sam and grasped my inner thighs, holding me up and spreading my legs open to show off the glistening fluids and cum coating my pussy. “Little brother, clean up the mess you’ve made of our baby sister,” he growled as he continued to bounce my ass on his cock.
Sam quickly climbed up and leaned over to eat my pussy and finger me. I was crying and I looked back to Ari, “I love you,” I whispered breathlessly to him.
He kissed me and thrust deep, pulling me tightly against him as the feeling of his warm cum spread deep in my ass, “Now I’ve had all of your firsts, Zia,” he whispered.
I nodded and he pulled his dick from my ass and looked at Sam, “Clean up the mess I made of her too, I’m gonna go wash my dick, I want her snuggled into bed between us when I get back.”
Sam smiled as he looked at Ari. I was gasping on the bed, leaning forward on my elbows with my ass still in the air. Sam climbed behind me and continued licking and sucking on my cunt until all of his cum was cleaned up, then he got to work on the hole Ari stretched around his cock. He fucking savored my ass, kissing and biting my cheeks between tonguing my brother’s cum from the hole.
When Ari got back, Sam was laying behind me, with his arms wrapped tightly around me. Ari climbed in front of me, lifting my leg over his hip as he pressed himself tighter to me, “I still hate myself for this…but I can be okay with it, if ‘brother’ and ‘sister’ is just a role play game for us and we stop introducing ourselves as actual siblings. You already have my last name…,” he said as he stroked my cheek and looked me in the eyes.
I nodded, “When we’re home we’re still brother and sister though?” I asked quietly.
He smiled, “Of course, baby sister,” he kissed my lips softly and I glanced at Sam.
“And him?” I asked.
Ari looked at Sam and reached back to stroke his cheek, “He’s your older brother and my younger brother and we’re going to teach him some of our games, if he’d like to learn them?” he said, directing the last bit of the question towards Sam.
“I thought you weren’t into guys?” Sam asked Ari.
Ari shrugged, “I thought I wasn’t into my sister either,” he offered.
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/i19gcr/getting_into_trouble_part_fourthe_end_incest_mfm
More
Don’t let this be the end!