This story is about the rest of my night with Erica. Since I already covered a lot of the build up, this should be a quicker story. I’ll put the links to the first 2 stories in a comment, but I’ll do a quick overview too. I first dated a girl named Connie while in high school. Later, I started a thing with her younger sister Erica. Erica gave me a blowjob right before we went to a party that her sister Connie would also be at.
So picking up where part 1 left off, Erica and I left my house and went to the party at my friend’s house. When we arrived, the party was already started. We got inside and got drinks, and right away ran into Connie, who had been there for a while already. She gave us a look that said “I know what you’ve been up to, and I’m not super happy about it”. Sensing where that might be going, Erica and I went outside to distance ourselves. We spent some time outside in the pool and the hot tub. It was really nice hanging out with Erica around my friends. She got along with them all well, and we were having a good time.
Pretty soon though, Connie came over and pulled Erica aside. When they got back, Erica let me know what the conversation was about. Connie had said Erica had to ride home with her, since she knew we would leave the party at some point to go hook up again. I guess she was trying to play the protective big sister role, but I think part of it was that since we had dated a year earlier, things were a little weird. Erica didn’t really care about that, and was just upset that Connie was trying to control her. She gave me a mischievous look and said “Fuck it. I’ll let her think she got her way, and we’ll just have to finish what we started here somewhere”. I was all on board for sneaking off somewhere to find a quiet place to have some fun.
We let some time pass, but about an hour later, I couldn’t wait anymore. We saw Connie in the hot tub talking to some people, and took our chance to sneak inside. We went upstairs, to my friend’s sister’s room. She wasn’t home, and my friend generally didn’t let people in there when he threw parties, so we figured it wouldn’t be the first place Connie might look if she came looking for us.
Unfortunately, the door didn’t have a lock, so we moved a chair in front of the door to try to block it, or at least give us warning if someone opened the door. I took one of the towels we had wrapped around us and laid it down on the floor on the other side of the bed from the door. Erica laid down on it on her back, and I moved in for a kiss. We made out just for a short time, and I started moving my hand to her waist. Before I really even got started, she lifted her hips up and slid her bikini bottoms off. I trailed my fingers on the inside of her thighs and moved them to her mound. She was already so wet, and I just lightly played with her clit, until she bucked her hips up in to my hand and told me to stop messing around. I laughed and dove in with my tongue. She immediately moaned loudly, so I stopped and told her she had to stay quiet. She told me she wasn’t scared of her sister finding us, but pulled the pillow to her face anyway. I went back down on her, and teased around her lips and opening, before moving up to really push on her clit with my tongue. It wasn’t long before she pulled me up and kissed me, and said “Enough foreplay, fuck me already”.
Unfortunately, I was planning for us to go back to my house after the party, and was stupid and didn’t bring a condom with me. I told her that, and she groaned, gave me a playful glare, then said she was on the pill and to just do it already. I didn’t need to be told twice, so I lined up, and started to push in. She was incredibly wet, but still so tight that it was not going in easy. She spit on her hand, and grabbed my shaft and lubed it up more, then really pulled me into her. When the head popped in, she moaned really loudly again, so I covered her mouth with my hand. I slowly sunk all the way into her, before pulling almost all the way out, just leaving the head in. We locked eyes, and I shoved all of it back into her. Her eyes bulged, and she moaned into my hand. I did that again, keeping the pace slow at first to give myself some time to enjoy how sexy she was like this. I gradually ramped up the pace, until I was steadily giving her long hard stokes. She grabbed my arms and bucked her hips up to mine and then came really hard. I slowed down to let her enjoy the orgasm, and then went in for a long kiss.
After she recovered a bit, I pulled out and flipped her over onto her stomach. I leaned back to take a second to admire her round ass, and then grabbed both cheeks and spread her so I could watch my tip go in. I pushed my hips forward till my tip was touching her lips, and let go of her ass with one hand to guide it in. As I slid fully back into her, I had to lean down to lightly bite her neck to keep from moaning myself. From her shudder, I guess she liked the biting, so I kept nibbling at her neck as I started very slowly with the long strokes again. I was so glad I had flipped her over, because the feeling of her ass against me as I was fully inside her was incredible. I leaned back up to admire the view, and grab her ass cheeks again. I felt like I wouldn’t last much longer, and told her I would come soon. She told me to pull out, so I could come in her mouth. That didn’t help with me trying to hold my orgasm in, so I gave her a few more hard strokes, and pulled out. She flipped over and sat up to put my tip into her mouth just in time. She sucked hard as I shot rope after rope into her mouth. After I was done, she pulled off and swallowed, looking me right in the eyes the whole time. She smiled and said “I figured that would make the clean up a lot easier”. I wasn’t going to complain, and was on cloud 9 after just coming in her mouth again.
Unfortunately, we couldn’t stay there long, and left to rejoin the party. Luckily, we weren’t gone long, and weren’t missed. We enjoyed the rest of the party, and then Connie called it a night and Erica left with her. The next day, Erica called me, and told me about the rest of her night. Apparently, Connie felt it was too weird for us to be together like this, and asked Erica if she would put an end to it. After having a more in depth discussion about it, and hearing more about why Connie felt that way, Erica said she didn’t want to ruin her relationship with her sister. I guess this had to do with their other sister Anna, who was a couple years older than Connie and I, and she had already gone to college by the time Connie and I dated, so I had never met her. Connie and Anna did not get along, and this thing with Erica apparently caused Connie to worry that she would not get along with her either. After hearing more about this all, I understood, and so we agreed that we would keep things as just friends between us, and other than some pretty heavy flirting occasionally, we kept our word.
I did however meet Anna eventually, which is another story I’ll share at some point.
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/hy0qe3/erica_sister_2_part_2_str8mf
The first 2 stories:
https://www.reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/hsrjz1/connie_sister_1_str8mforal/
https://www.reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/htfojn/erica_sister_2_part_1_str8mforal/