a very slutty love triangle (mmf/threesome/)?

this is a true story I never tell bc it makes me sound like such a slut. years ago I was dating a guy who was no good, borderline abusive in retrospect. I was young and stupid and stayed with him for way too long. He had always wanted to share me in a threesome with another guy, but I was super shy and nervous to do so, although it definitely interested me. Most of his friends were total losers, so whenever my bf would suggest someone who wanted to I would veto immediately. He had one friend (his best and oldest) that was different- a dreamy, quiet guy that my bf knew from high school that wasn’t like his other friends. The three of us hung out a lot, and i could tell this friend, the different one (let’s call him C) was into me. He was sweet and shy, but I sensed a darker side to his personality, which really drew me to him.

I asked my bf if we could have the threesome with C instead of this guy he had recently met who wanted to. He seemed annoyed and would rather one of his loser friends fuck me (I guess he just wasn’t intimidated by them) but eventually agreed to talk to C about it. To my delight, C was super into it.

We three got together soon after that. It started off with cuddling and kissing and escalated quickly from there. It was immediately clear that C and I had great chemistry, and my heart raced when he undressed me carefully, like a present. There was a bit of awkwardness bc my bf wanted things to move much faster but C wanted to take his time with me, as he had never seen me naked or touched my body before. This was clearly not what my bf wanted- he wanted something quick and dirty and to watch another man objectify me. But I was having the most intense sexual experience of my life- giving my body to this shy, brooding guy who was super into me and never thought he would get the chance. It was like my bf wasn’t there, and he could tell.

I was so focused on sucking on C’s cock that I didn’t notice that my bf has gotten up and left after fucking me from behind for a few minutes. After a while, I decided it would be unfair to fuck C with my bf in the other room pouting, so I finished sucking him off, swallowed his load and went to the other room to ask my bf what was wrong, although I totally knew already.

My bf was super mad at both of us for being fixated on each other during our threesome. He asked C if I had made him cum and he lied and said no. My bf said the arrangement wasn’t going to work for him, and we couldn’t do it anymore. I was heartbroken bc I wanted to fuck C so badly. I was upset but understood why my bf felt the way he did and tried to respect it. I walked C out of my bf’s apartment and hugged him goodbye.. to my surprise, he grabbed my ass under my skirt when I hugged him and grinned mischievously at me. My heart was racing which I stood up on my tip toes to kiss him quickly before he left. I was completely smitten.

C and i started texting constantly behind my bfs back, which I knew was bad but I couldn’t help it. I wanted him so much and felt very dissatisfied with how our encounter had ended. he asked me to meet him at a park to talk. By the time we met it was dark out and hardly anyone else was around. we walked and talked a little, and tbh my panties were drenched just walking around talking to him. he told me he didn’t get to do what he had wanted with me the other day. we walked deeper into the park and stopped at a picnic table in a little grove of trees, where he laid me down and fucked me harder than I have ever been fucked before. The desire he had for me made it unbelievably intense. he was simultaneously adoring of my body and completely manhandling me, giving me everything I could take. we hadn’t talked about doing it beforehand, and he didn’t wear a condom… I was afraid I might get pregnant but I didn’t care. He walked me home and held my hand, while I tried to keep his cum from rolling all the way down my legs…

We kept meeting and fucking behind my bfs back. We had fallen completely in love, and were taking constantly. I felt like such a slut for fucking my boyfriend’s best friend behind his back, but it only added to the intensity of our relationship. Eventually I broke up with my boyfriend without telling him what C and I had been doing. He was angry and confused but I cut him off completely. I ruined his and C’s friendship forever, and they still don’t speak today. I used to feel guilty… I don’t anymore:)

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/gwai5h/a_very_slutty_love_triangle_mmfthreesome