Truth or Dare [MFF] [exh]

This is my first erotic story. This is just part one of ? Not sure how many parts to this there will be (if any). It’s a little tame (have little time to write these days), but any future installments will be significantly less tame. Hopefully this is still entertaining though, enjoy!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Jess flirted with girls at the bar before but this was different, she never actually picked anyone up to come home with us before. We have had discussions about the possibility of a threesome but usually that’s all it was, a discussion. We were both open to the idea but I didn’t think it would ever happen. If it did, I knew Jess would pick the girl (or guy) to bring home with us. I could pick someone up if I wanted to, but Jess had an allure to her that drew people to her. She was extremely beautiful, 5’6”, long auburn hair, and deep green eyes that I could never look away from. Her eyes were the type that seemed to stare through a person and into their soul but there was warmth and a comfort in them, which no matter what mood I was in, told me everything would be ok. She also has the most incredible body; a perfect hourglass shape, wide hips, double-d tits, and an ass that made most guys turn around as she walked by. Now I am no slouch, I’m about 6-foot, have dark black hair, a medium to athletic build, but in my opinion Jess is way out of my league.

A couple of times a month, Jess and I head over to the local watering hole to hang out and unwind from a long week. Usually on these nights out, we play a sort of truth or dare game at the bar; just without the truth portion. Nothing ever got out of hand; the most extreme dare on record was for Jess to grab the waitress’ ass as she walked by. Usually the dares were tame and silly like obtain someone’s hat, or get a free drink. Tonight I gave Jess a pretty typical dare; I picked out someone I thought was attractive and told Jess to go get a drink from her. She happily agreed. She teased me as she sauntered over to the unwitting patron, flipping the back of her skirt up, flashing me a quick shot of her perfect ass. She usually wore clothes that were on the risqué side so she could tease me while we were out. This always ended with me tearing her clothes off before we even got back in the house. Tonight, being a balmy 87 degree night in July she opted to wear a low cut black dress that outlined her figure quite well. I also noticed she was not wearing any panties.

The girl I had dared Jess to talk to look pretty shy, shoulder length brown hair, pretty skinny, she looked to be about a B-cup. I definitely do not mind girls with smaller tits, I am just more of an ass man. Unfortunately, I was unable to get a glimpse of the girl’s backside from my viewing angle at the table. But there was something in her face that was very sensual. I noticed her on our way into the bar and didn’t pay her any mind but after getting our drinks and settling in my gaze kept getting drawn to her.

Apparently, Jess and the girl had quite a bit in common. They chatted and giggled for about 15 minutes when they both walked over to our table.

“Babe, this is Samantha. Samantha this is my boyfriend Joe.” Jess said, she seemed quite excited to introduce the two of us.

“Please call me Sam.” Said Sam, I barely made out what she said over the loud music. She stirred her drink with her straw and barely made eye contact.

“Nice to meet you Sam, could I get you another drink? It looks like you could use a fresh one.” I replied trying to make her more comfortable. She nodded her head and asked for a Vodka and cranberry juice.

“I will have the same!” Said Jess, giving me her best puppy-dog eye look. I went and got the drinks and we chatted for a good half hour after I got back. Sam eventually warmed up to me. My guess is the vodka had started to kick in. After we finished our fourth round Jess suggested we head back to our place for more drinks in an environment better suited for conversation. To my surprise Sam agreed. Jess and I did not drive to the bar so we could both drink and Sam had apparently done the same so I ordered us an Uber. Jess sat in the middle seat on the drive home and had some girl talk with Sam, meanwhile; Jess’ hand found its way to my crotch and rubbed my cock over my pants. I think Sam saw what Jess was doing but I can’t be sure, either way Jess rubbing my cock with two strangers in the car made me hard as a rock. It took about 20 minutes to get back to our house. Jess hopped out of the car and practically dragged Sam inside excited for the events that would follow. I was able to finally get a look at Sam’s ass. It did not disappoint. She didn’t quite have the body Jess did, but she obviously worked out because she was toned and had a nice figure.

“Would you like something a little more comfortable?” Jess asked Sam, gesturing to her dress. “I have some shorts and a t-shirt you could borrow if you like?”

“No thank you, I am fine. Honestly I am not sure how long I am going to stay.” Replied Sam.

“OK well if you change your mind let me know, I am going to get comfortable. Babe could you make some drinks for us?”

“Already on it,” I said, reaching for the bottle of vodka in the freezer.

“Um, Joe, where is your bathroom?” asked Sam, she stood in the middle of our living room not really sure if she should sit or leave.

“Right down this hall, first door on your left.” I said, pointing her down the main hallway. I heard the bathroom door close right as Jess walked into the kitchen. She changed into a tank top and some cotton shorts.

“I think she is nervous about being here,” I whispered.

“Don’t worry, she wants to be here.” Replied Jess.

“Oh? How do you know?”

“Trust me.” Said Jess with a devilish grin. After I finished the drinks and Sam finished in the bathroom we settled in the living room. Sam and Jess were sitting on the couch; Jess continued to flirt with Sam and worked to make her more comfortable. I settled into the love seat on the other side of our coffee table, jumping in the conversation when I could.

“I have an idea, though it might seem kind of silly.” Said Sam, I couldn’t tell if she was blushing or just flushed from the alcohol. “You guys want to play truth or dare?”

Jess grinned from ear to ear and we both quickly agreed.

“I will start!” I said, eager to get things going. “Jess, Truth or Dare?”

“Truth,” she replied.

“What is the weirdest thing you ever ate?” I asked. I wanted to start things off slow, better to hold the fun stuff for later.

“I once ate a worm for $1 in 5th grade. Yea I was that girl.” Laughed Jess, Sam made a Yuck noise and giggled along with her.

“Ok my turn, Sam, truth or dare?”

“Dare.” Said Sam. To my surprise she’d opened up quite a bit and was quite eager for whatever Jess would throw at her. Knowing Jess it wouldn’t be as tame as my question.

“I dare you to kiss me.” Said Jess, biting her bottom lip. Sam turned, put her hand behind Jess’ neck and kissed her. I never saw Jess make out with anyone else before, it was incredibly hot. They kissed for roughly 30 seconds then Sam turned to me.

“Truth or dare?” she asked.

“Truth,” she looked slightly disappointed with my answer.

“What is your dirtiest fantasy?” she asked. Jess looked at me eager to hear my answer and take down some notes for the future.

“I have always wondered what it would be like to be pegged.” I replied, and shot a quick glance at Jess. She seemed very excited, and would probably bring it up sometime in the near future.

“Whoa, definitely did not expect that one!” exclaimed Sam as she looked at Jess to see what her reaction was.

“Ok my turn!” I said. I felt my face getting hot. I had never mentioned to Jess before that I had wondered what it would be like to have her peg me. Partly because I knew she would want to do it. “Jess, truth or dare?”

“Dare,” this time I wasn’t going to hold back.

“I dare you to take off your shirt.” Completely unfazed by this she stripped off her shirt. It was easy to tell she wasn’t wearing a bra, her nipples practically ripped through the tank top. Sam was mesmerized, unable to look away from Jess’ bare chest.

“You can touch them if you like.” Said Jess to Sam. A bolt of excitement shot through me at the thought of seeing Jess fondled by another girl.

“Maybe later,” teased Sam.

“Ok Babe, truth or dare?” said Jess turning to me.

“Dare,” I said, giving her a mischievous grin.

“I dare you…” She paused as she thought of a worthwhile dare. “I dare you to ding dong ditch the Johnson’s across the street…naked.” She shot me that devilish grin and bit her bottom lip. Without saying anything I got up and stripped off my clothes. I was still slightly hard from watching Jess and Sam kiss, but I got much harder when I saw Sam’s eyes drop to my cock. I winked at Jess and walked out the front door.

I felt the girls watching me through the front window as I walked across the street planning my escape route. There was a set of bushes next to the Johnson’s front door I could jump into, but that seemed kind of painful given my outfit. I decided that the best escape route would be to run around to the left side of their house and hide around the corner, the right side had a motion activated floodlight. I walked up their steps preparing myself to bolt to the left after hitting their doorbell. Right as I hit their doorbell a car passed by and honked their horn, which caught me off guard. I realized it was not a cop as they passed they just saw me and wanted to let me know. I heard footsteps from inside the house.

Shit! I thought as a light come on inside through the door window. The car distracted me and foiled my escape. I bolted to the left hoping I would make it to the side of their house before Ed or Donna opened the door. I heard the door open as I rounded the corner.

“Goddamn kids!” Ed exclaimed as he realized what happened and slammed the door. I waited till the coast was clear and headed back to my house.

The girls were laughing hysterically as I walked in; amused by the fact that Ed almost caught me naked on his porch and that a passing stranger did catch me.

“Aww my friend went away.” Said Jess in a pouty voice, motioning to my no longer erect penis.

“Ha. Ha.” I shot back as I put my pants back on. I didn’t bother putting my shirt or underwear back on since I knew the pants wouldn’t be on much longer. “Ok my turn!” I said, ready for my revenge. “Sam, truth or dare?”

“Dare,” she said, undressing me with her eyes.

“I dare you to give me a lap dance and strip,” Sam turned and whispered something to Jess, who assured her it was fine.

Sam got up and selected a song to dance to, she chose Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This) by the Eurhythmics. At least she has good taste in music. She walked over and spread out my legs and started to grind her ass on my dick. I wouldn’t be surprised if she was a stripper, she gave me a Grade A lap dance. I became rock hard, which excited her and she get into the dance even more. Still turned away from me she pulled her dress over her head and leaned back putting her head on my shoulder. I glanced over at Jess and saw her put her hand down her cotton shorts. I kissed Sam’s neck and reached around with both hands to squeeze her tits. They fit nicely into my hands and she ground her ass on me even more vigorously. All of the teasing from earlier had taken its toll and I struggled to hold back an orgasm. Thankfully, the song ended, but Sam wasn’t done. She turned around and passionately kissed me while she rubbed her pussy on my fully erect cock. Seconds before I was about to cum, Jess cleared her throat very loudly, in an attempt to get our attention. Sam broke the kiss and looked over at Jess embarrassed.

“Sorry,” she said, moving to pick up her discarded dress. Her face started to turn bright red.

“Don’t be sorry,” replied Jess. “That was incredibly hot to watch. I just think we can have a lot more fun before this devolves into sex. Babe, go get the hot tub ready. Sam, you come with me, I have just the thing for you to wear. Leave the dress, you won’t need it anymore.” Jess grabbed Sam’s hand, gave me a wink, and led her off to the bedroom.

Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/715hnw/truth_or_dare_mff_exh