“It’s just hard to see her like this, John.” Pearl sighed softly, watching her friend Lily walk to her car eyes firmly at the ground whenever she passed someone. Pearl’s boyfriend put his arm around her comfortingly as they watched Lily get in the car and drive off. “She barely even talks to me anymore, and I’ve known her since kinder garden.”
“I know, but what can we really do?” John asked. “I don’t think she can even look a man in the eyes anymore, let alone get anyone to… help her.” He gave his girlfriend a soft squeeze. “I feel for her too, you know that. I mean she used to come over all the time when we first moved in together. I lost a dear friend too.”
“I know she misses talking with you as well. I know you mean a lot to her… she used to joke that she was only visiting to try to steal you away from me.” She let out a soft giggle at the memory but it faded as she stood quietly and thought.
“What are you thinking about?” John asked her softly, knowing her well enough to know she was mulling something over.
“Maybe… Maybe you could help her.” She finally said.
—
Lily had gotten home at 5.30 pm, but she hadn’t headed up to her apartment before 6 pm. She wanted to be sure Mr. Bergeson was watching the news so she wouldn’t run into him. Just a few months ago she would have enjoyed a talk with the older handsome gentleman about the weather and what new taxes the government was going to push on them next, but not now.
Ever since she had been hit by that curse, every social interaction seemed like torture. Just imagining someone thinking about her made her cheeks flush and having a whole conversation with someone just seemed ludicrous. She didn’t seem to know how to be around anyone anymore, and how was she ever to break a curse that made her so desperately shy, when the only way to break it was for a man to bless her with a child to carry.
She still went to visit Pearl every few weeks, she was Lily’s oldest and best friend and even worse than having to string together conversations and small talks for hours, was the thought of losing her best friend. She felt ashamed of herself, of how she treated Pearl, and how she hadn’t even been able to look John in the eyes yet. He was just so… her cheeks reddened again and she curled up on the couch, unable to continue the thought.
She thought of Pearl and John and with red cheeks she reached down, closing her eyes as if to ignore her own actions. She undid her long modest skirt and slipped a hand inside, she felt horrified with herself as she imagined Johns toned upper body as she had seen it coming out of the shower a few years prior. She touched the thick white panties softly as she imagined a hand caressing his chest, not her own, Pearl’s hand. She let out a soft whimper as she saw Pearl in her minds eye, still as perky and beautiful as when they used to shower together at college. Lily touched herself through the fabric as she imagined Pearls lips meeting John’s and a hand slowly gliding down towards his slowly hardening-
The creaking of the floor made Lily jump with shock, pulling her hand to herself and snapping her eyes open. She looked towards the door and saw. “N-no, you- you saw?” She whimpered as she cast her eyes downwards.
“I’m just here to help you.” John’s voice was gentle and reassuring as he stepped into the living room, leaving Pearl’s spare key on the table by the door. “Pearl and I, we can’t stand to see you like this.” He moved closer in slow measured steps, like a man approaching a cornered dog, careful not to frighten it.
“P-pearl sent you?” She barely got the words out as she inched backwards on the couch, grabbing a blanket and pulling it up over her, keeping her eyes on his feet.
“It was her idea, but we both agree that this is the only way we can help you.” He said softly as he reached the couch and sat down furthest away from her. “I just want to see you smile again Lily, I want my friend back.” She saw his hand move towards her slowly but she didn’t move away from it. It came to rest on her foot where it poked out from beneath the blanket. “Please, let me help you.” He said with a gentle voice and gave her foot a light squeeze.
She was shaking all over when she forced her gaze up to meet his, she couldn’t get herself to speak but she managed a small frightened nod.
“I won’t hurt you Lily, and I won’t force anything on you.” John said with loving eyes. “It needs to be your decision, you need to say it.”
She stared at him in shock as her heart raced so fast she thought it was going to jump right out of her chest. “Please.” She finally managed through trembling lips. “Help me.”
—
She felt so weak in his arms, shaking against his chest as he carried her into her bedroom. He closed the door behind them with a foot and without the light of the living room flooding in the bedroom was dark. He wasn’t going to turn on the light, he didn’t want to make her feel worse about this. He lay her down on the bed softly and followed her down to the bed. He watched her shaking figure in the dark and leaned in close, kissing her trembling lips. She didn’t move away, and John thought she might even have pushed back against his lips a little.
John pulled the covers up over both of them and put a hand on her side, just softly caressing her side and every once in a while giving her another small kiss. Slowly but surely the shaking seemed to subside, she was in her own bed, under her own covers and it seemed she was slowly starting to feel better.
“I’m sorry if I scared you.” He whispered softly to her as he let his hand trail down her side and come to rest on her hip. “I will never ever hurt you Lily, you are too dear to me for me to ever hurt you.” He kissed her again. “I’m going to get undressed now, you don’t have to watch.” He assured her as he kicked off his shoes and started to undo his pants. They soon joined the shoes on the floor at the foot of the bed and John was left in just a T-shirt and his boxers under the cover in the darkened room. His hand found her hip again and was relieved that it hadn’t started shaking again. He leaned close and kissed her soft lips once more. “I’ll be gentle and I’ll make you feel wonderful.” He assured her as his hand on her hip grabbed the loose skirt and slipped it off of her legs entirely. He heard her breath go more jagged and fearful when his fingers found the side of her panties though and so came to a halt. “I’ll make you feel like yourself again, and I’ll make sure you enjoy every minute of it.” He whispered softly to her. “No pain, no shame, no fear.” He assured her as he caressed her hip. “I’ll just make you feel as loved and as wonderful as you are.” He listened intensely to her breath in the dark and it slowly calmed down once more. He leaned in and kissed her as his fingers gripped the panties and slipped them off of her as they shared one another’s lips.
He felt his own member starting to rise when he ran his fingers up the inside of her thigh and found her more private place. He could feel it was already damp, probably from what he had seen her do on the couch. Skilled fingers found her clit and began to softly rub it. She let out a loud gasp when he touched her there and his other hand went up to her face, cupping her chin reassuringly. “It’s okay.” He shushed her softly. “I’m going to be gentle. I won’t hurt you.” He assured her as he slowly massaged her clit and it grew hard beneath his fingers.
The shocked gasp had soon turned to soft moans as he kept rubbing her and he was happy that she didn’t react as strongly when he let a finger slip down and run through her slit. He kept a thumb on her clit, rubbing it as he let his other fingers seek out her cave and one finger slowly push inside. He could feel her tense up as it pushed inside her, but another soft kiss seemed to do wonders to relax her. John reached down with her free hand and managed to push his boxers down to let his own substantial member free. He moved over on top of her, making sure his fingers kept up their work and he saw her shake a little in the darkness below him.
“Are you okay?” He asked her concerned. “If you want me to stop, I will.” He assured her shivering form.
“No, please.” She almost whimpered. “I need this, I need you.” Her voice pleading for him made his heart skip a beat and he reached for his cock with his free hand.
“Don’t worry. I will take care of you, I will always be here for you when you need me.” He assured her as he stroked his cock to make sure it was as hard as it could be. “Now, I’m going to show you just how much you mean to me.” He said lovingly as he pulled his fingers out of her and coated his cock in the juices stuck to his fingers. He leaned down low over her and positioned himself, his cock pressing against her opening.
He hesitated for a moment, praying to whatever higher power was out there that he was doing the right thing, then he pushed the head inside her. She clutched the bed sheets tightly as he entered her, and went completely quiet, not even breathing as she just clung on to the minuscule feeling of control she felt clutching the sheets gave her. He gave her another soft kiss on the lips, not moving his cock in further and eventually, she drew breath again. “I love you.” He whispered to her as he pushed in deeper. “Just as much as I love Pearl.” He ran a hand through her hair as he pushed in further. “and she loves you just as deeply.” He assured her as he stopped his slowmotion penetration.
“I… I… love you too.” Lily managed to whimper out and John felt a surge of emotions running through him. He kissed her again as he slowly started pulling out of her and then pushing back in. He was going as slow as he had gone since that first night with Pearl years and years ago, but Lily was responding beneath him. Not with the fear of before, but with soft pleasurable moans that made him certain that what he was doing was right. He fucked her in long slow thrusts, never pushing in too deep and never thrusting too hard, he was there to make her feel loved and to help her break the curse and hopefully not lose a woman he loved in the process.
“H-“ Lily barely got the sound past her lips before she bit her lip in embarrassment. “Ha-harder.” She forced herself to finish and John responded. He buried his cock deeper inside her with every thrust and each thrust came faster than the last. Soon her moans were mixed with his heavy breathing and occasional lustful remarks of: “Fuck you feel good.” Or “I love you so much.”.
John could feel himself nearing his climax as he fucked her and felt her cave tighten around his cock with every thrust. “I’m going to give you- all my love.” He breathed heavily as he leaned down and kissed her once more, but this time her lips opened up for him and invited his tongue inside. It played with her timid tongue as he kept thrusting and suddenly the walls of her sex clasped around him like a vice as orgasmic tremors of pleasure rolled through her entire body. He came with a muffled groan and felt the cum pumping through his cock and being unloaded deep inside her. His hips kept thrusting almost involuntarily as his cock fired its second and third spurt of life giving seed into her. He was still kissing her when his cock finally stopped throbbing and the last cum seeped out inside of her, but the kiss had changed.
He felt his tongue being pushed back and suddenly her tongue was in his mouth. Her arms went up and wrapped themselves around him, holding him tightly as she kissed him. They lay for a bit like that, tongues dancing, pelvises locked together and sweat dripping off of them. When she finally broke the kiss it was her who spoke first.
“God John… You have no idea how good that felt.” Even in the dark he could sense her smirk, a smirk he hadn’t seen since she had been cursed.
“It’s good to have you back.” He smiled down to her in the dark, thankful to hear the playful tone in her voice again, he tried to push off of her but she held him down on top of her.
“It’s good to be back.” She said softly as she leaned up and gave him a soft kiss before she let him go. John flopped off of her and down onto the bed besides her, and she soon turned onto her side and watched him panting and breathing in the dark. “Those things you said…” She began quietly. “Did you mean them?”
John weighed his options and considered the talk he had had with Pearl before he left. “Every single one.” He assured her.
“You know what breaking the curse means… right?” Lily asked as she absentmindedly brushed a few fingers across her stomach, realizing that it wouldn’t stay that flat for long.
“I do.” John said as he got onto his side to face her in the darkness as well. “You are pregnant now.” He said as he reached out and took her hand, folding his fingers with hers on her stomach. “With me.”
Lily nodded in the darkness. “So… What now?” She asked hesitantly.
“That is up to you.” John said as he took her hand up to his lips and kissed the back of her hand. “I love you, and Pearl loves you too. If you want to, we would love it if you would turn our couple into a triple.” He said.
“Are you serious?” Lily asked, her voice so full of surprise John wasn’t sure if it was out of happiness or not.
“If you feel the same way about us as we do about you.” He said softly. “We will never abandon you, and I would never make you carry my baby if I wasn’t 100% sure I wanted to raise it with you as well.” John assured her.
“I…” Lily began but instead of continuing she just leaned in close and gave him a long loving kiss. “I would love to.”
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/6h992b/wpshes_been_cursed_with_a_debilitating_shyness