The throbbing beat of the subwoofers made the gin and tonic in Toby's glass quiver in time with the music. He sipped again as his eyes scanned the room for fresh meat. The new semester always brought in guys looking to find out if that twitch they got glancing around the communal showers in high school meant something. And Toby considered himself the best person to answer all their questions.
One guy caught his eye because of the timid way he approached the bar. He was in good shape judging from the way his tight jeans and UCF soccer jersey outlined his muscles. Toby stepped closer before anyone else could and leaned against the bar next to him without getting too close. He drained his gin and tonic and put the glass down hard.
"Boris! Can I get another gin and tonic?" Boris the bartender was only wearing a bow tie and tight leather pants. Despite his cut, muscular body he was currently off the market dating the owner. Such a pity.
"Can I get a bud?" The soccer jersey guy asked.
"You have to ask louder than than," Toby said as he leaned closer, then turned to face the bartender again. "Hey Boris! Add a bud to my tab."
"You got it, Toby!" He grinned as he glanced at the fresh meat.
"What's your name," Toby said as he caught a whiff of the new guy's personal scent. Total virgin.
"Mark," the guy said without meeting Toby's eyes. "You're Toby obviously."
Toby turned around to keep an eye on the club, but it was more an excuse to get closer and see Mark's face. "That I am. You go to school here?"
"This fall," he said as Boris handed him the beer with a glance at his banded wrist.
"So how'd you get in here with a wrist band," Toby said as he tucked his finger under the rainbow colored band and pulled.
Mark blushed. "I got an ID."
Young and tender… When Mark didn't pull away, Toby leaned closer. "So are you meeting someone here?"
"No." Mark finally looked up and met Toby's eyes. "I have no idea what I'm doing here."
Toby caught an unmistakable hunger in his expression. Toby leaned in and whispered against his cheek, "I bet I do."
Mark leaned his face against Toby's cheek and took a deep shuddering breath. "I don't know if I can do this," he whispered just barely loud enough to hear.
"I know you can," Toby said and kissed his rough skin. Mark sighed and gripped Toby's arm. "Come home with me for a while. No one will ever know."
"Where?" Mark growled.
"Upstairs in the apartments above this place," Toby said, then nudged Mark's face until he could kiss his lips.
Mark's lips were limp at first, but Toby drew him in with a playful nip. In moments Mark responded with a hungry kiss that opened to Toby's slippery tongue. The kiss deepened as the men turned to face each other. Toby gripped the soccer jersey in his fists while Mark pulled to grind their erections together. "I want this."
"I can tell," Toby chuckled and gave Boris a look. "I'll settle up later."
"Have fun," Boris said with a knowing grin.
Toby led Mark to the elevators just outside the entrance to the club. The doors opened as soon as Toby pushed the button. He gripped Mark's jersey again and dragged him into the elevator, pressing the sixth floor before allowing Mark to push him against the wall to kiss him again.
Toby tugged the jersey out of his pants to run his hands up inside. Mark had amazing muscle definition, Toby thought as he kissed down to his neck. Mark was panting into his hair while Toby teased his hairy nipples to points.
Sucking his breath through his teeth, Mark found Toby's lips again and reached down to run his hands along the stiff cock inside Toby's jeans.
"Fuck yes," Toby groaned into his mouth. When the door opened, Toby pushed Mark back with a gentle grin. "Come with me."
After Toby fished his keys out and opened his apartment door, he lead Mark inside and through the dark living room to his bedroom. When they stopped, Mark got a scared look on his face. "I don't know…"
"Shh," Toby said as he tugged Mark's shirt off. "It'll be fine, just relax." Mark looked even better than he'd felt as Toby took in the sight of him. Kissing again, Toby placed his hands on his buttons to encourage Mark to do the same. His hands trembled as he opened each button. "I'm so hot for you."
Mark was flushed as he opened the shirt and moved down to his belt and jeans. "I want to feel you."
In moments the jeans were open and Toby had kicked off his jeans revealing his thick, veined cock standing out from a short thatch of pubic hair. His cut head was already leaking when he placed Mark's hand on it. "It's ready for you."
Mark stared down at the cock moving through his fist, his eyes glassy with hunger. "It's so hot."
While he was transfixed, Toby opened Mark's jeans and pushed them down along with his boxer briefs. Mark was just as thick and a little longer with a decided curve up. "So is yours," he said as he brought them to rub together.
"I've sucked one before," Mark said in a strained whisper. "He was my best friend, but I fucked it all up."
Toby tried to gauge how far he could push things, but Mark seemed content to stroke him. He kept stroking Mark with one hand while he began to touch him on his chest and face with the other. It seemed to bring Mark back and he began kissing Toby again. Using a light touch, Toby reached around to run his fingers along Mark's ass. "Can I make you feel good?"
Mark stopped kissing, his face flushed red. "I did him, I never let him do me." The pain on his face made him pinch his lips and blink hard.
The confession was heartbreaking and made Toby pause. "Hey, if you just want to do me it's cool. Come on." He climbed into the bed and got the lube and condoms he kept in the nightstand. Ordinarily Toby would just talk the guy into it, but something about Mark seemed fragile and touched him. Before he could get ready, Mark sat down and stopped him.
"I need to know why it mattered so much," Mark said, keeping his eyes on Toby's. "I have to understand."
"Are you sure?" Toby said, his cock twitching back to an aching erection at the idea of plumbing his virgin depths.
"Yeah," he whispered. "I blew it with him, but I still need to know what I'm missing. Will you show me?"
Toby nodded and got up for a second to arrange the pillows. "Lie down here and put your hips on the pillow."
Mark was shaking as he positioned himself on the bed. "Does it hurt?"
"No," Toby smiled at him. "It feels wonderful. You just need to relax."
Toby sat between his legs and got his hands slick with lube. He started by stroking Mark's shaft and playing with his balls. When Mark shut his eyes and sighed, Toby began to massage his thighs and stomach as well. When his cock began to leak, Toby pushed his legs open and allowed his fingers to tickle under Mark's balls.
"It feels nice," Mark whispered in wonder.
"Try not to tense up." Toby took his time as he filled an applicator with lube. He kept touching the puckered circle of skin until Mark opened on his own, then he slowly slipped the applicator inside. "It may feel a little cool."
Mark bit his lip until Toby had filled him and removed the applicator, then Mark gave a thin smile. Using his fingers, Toby kept working him until Mark started pushing against his touches. He quickly slipped on a condom with one hand, then moved closer until the head of his cock replaced his fingers. Mark didn't even seem to notice at first as he pushed back against the intrusion.
When he was halfway in, Mark opened his eyes with a look of surprise. "It doesn't hurt at all."
"Of course not," Toby chuckled. "Just wait."
When his stomach touched Mark's balls he lifted Mark's legs up with his arms and withdrew about halfway, then pushed back in just as slowly.
"Holy shit," Mark whispered and shut his eyes again. "It's amazing."
Toby worked him along until he could handle faster paced thrusting. As Mark rocked against his thrusts his cock began to leak all over his stomach. Toby held himself back to allow Mark to enjoy the full effect of the stimulation, but eventually watching his virgin conquest brought him to the edge.
He pumped some more lube into his hand and gripped Mark's shaft while he continued to work his tight asshole. "I want you to cum for me," Toby whispered. "Show me how much you like this."
"Oh fuck," Mark groaned. "Oh fuck!"
The tightening ring of muscle pushed Toby over the edge as Mark shot what seemed like gallons of cum up his stomach and chest. Watching Mark's face the whole time, Toby filled the condom until he thought it would explode. In the final throws of their passion, Toby leaned down and kissed Mark with a wild abandon while Mark kissed and bit his lips in return. The moment passed and they cooled down, slicked together with the result of their lust.
"Do you get it now?" Toby asked as he rested against Mark's broad chest.
"I was an idiot." Mark rubbed his forehead and eyes to hide the tears, but Toby could see him struggling. "He wanted to kiss me after and I got scared."
"What did he do?"
"Left me for a guy who would kiss him like this," he said and wrapped his arms around Toby's neck and kissed him deeply. Their tongues touched, then pressed together as they tried to dominate each other with their mouths alone. In the end Toby let him win, then wrapped him up and kissed the pain away with soft nips along his cheeks and jaw.
After Toby withdrew, they lay together for a while until he noticed Mark's cock stirring back to life. "You up for another round? I'd like to feel what you can do with that." He reached down and stroked Mark while he gave him a sly look.
"I think I'd like to show you."
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/3a4gb4/mark_figures_it_out_mmanal